Unspoken Secrets and Old Memories

Texts and Angel Feathers

 

From Chanyeol: “Hey Byun Baek! I don’t know if the calendar days are the same up in heaven, but Happy Birthday!”

It’d been months since the accident.

Baekhyun smiled down to his phone and pretended to type a reply that he knew Chanyeol wouldn’t get.

From Chanyeol: “I got you a present – one that I know you want.”

Baekhyun didn’t miss Chanyeol at all. It was practically like they were still together.

Baekhyun mouthed a sarcastically surprised “oh?” to his phone before smiling again and typing “What was it?”

From Chanyeol: “But I can’t tell you because then it’ll ruin the secret. So shh!”

Baekhyun laughed as he lay back on his bed, typing to busy his fingers while waiting for Chanyeol’s next text. This was how the conversations always went. Chanyeol would text him, Baekhyun would pretend that Chanyeol could hear him reply or read his unsent responses. Chanyeol would carry on a conversation by himself and tell Baekhyun about his day, and Baekhyun would listen contentedly, appreciative of the attention.

From Chanyeol: “But I’ve always been bad with keeping secrets from you….”

Baekhyun nodded to his phone and whispered, “Then hurry up and tell me!”

From Chanyeol: “So your gift is…. Me! :D”

Baekhyun’s smile widened as he typed back, “Yay! I love it!”

From Chanyeol: “You love it, right?! I knew you would!”

Baekhyun laughed and rolled over on his back, extending his arms all the way to hold his phone above his head, giggling like a school girl.

It was always like this. Baekhyun was always like this. Talking to Chanyeol took his worries away and threw him back into the time where nothing else mattered but the two of them.

Baekhyun had learned a lot from Chanyeol over the months that they had been texting. Since Christmas, Chanyeol had been texting more often. Once a week turned into twice a week, and now he was texting almost every day. Despite being interrupted often when he was studying a little for his job test, Baekhyun never minded the texts; he loved to hear Chanyeol rant about everything ranging from general updates about his day to random funny pictures that he found (including one of a small, fluffy dog wearing a top hat and bowtie that supposedly reminded Chanyeol of him). He learned that Chanyeol finally understood why Baekhyun hated math, he had learned some of Baekhyun’s favorite songs on his guitar, everyone was slowly getting more apathetic as they neared graduation, and even that Kyungsoo and Jongin had started dating (though they pretty much denied it at every chance they had – Chanyeol could tell from the hand holding or small pecks on the cheek and some rare make out sessions in the library that it was true). Recently, Baekhyun had been visiting The Observatory more often to watch his group of friends mess around with each other, and he would smile at them, shaking his head at the stupid things they did.

From Chanyeol: “You’re so predictable, Baek. Or maybe I’m just too good.”

Baekhyun smiled and playfully stuck out his tongue.

From Chanyeol: “I actually still have your Christmas present too. I couldn’t give it back or to someone else…”

Baekhyun’s smile froze.

From Chanyeol: “You know, your mom and my mom and Kyungsoo and everyone… they say I should stop buying gifts for you.”

Baekhyun stared at his phone, frowning as he replied, “You probably should. It hurts you more.”

From Chanyeol: “Everyone says I should stop texting you too.”

Baekhyun sat up slowly and stared at his phone.

From Chanyeol: “But how can I do that…? I’m supposed to hold on forever, right? We promised we would never leave each other. Why should I change that now?”

From Chanyeol: “I know you don’t get these or whatever but sometimes… why can’t people just let me pretend? Why can’t you just let me pretend?”

Baekhyun’s chest tightened. He never wished that he could respond to Chanyeol more than he wanted to right then. He wanted to tell him that he shouldn’t pretend, and that he wouldn’t let him hurt himself like that. He wanted to say he shouldn’t need to pretend – that he was still with him always. He wanted to tell him everything would be alright. But he wasn’t that sure either.

From Chanyeol: “… you know, nevermind. I’m sorry – it’s your birthday and all. You should be happy, right? ^_^ Happy birthday, Byun Baek! You’re officially 19! Enjoy it and use your present well ;)”

Baekhyun frowned, frozen in his spot, waiting for another text from Chanyeol. When one didn’t come, he set down his phone and sighed into his hands as the door opened slowly.

“Byun?” Baekhyun glanced up to the sound of Jongdae’s voice. “Are you ready to go out?” Noticing his slumped position, he added tentatively, “Do you even still want to go out…?” Baekhyun blinked in Jongdae’s direction, suddenly remembering that he and his friends were planning on spending the entire day out.

Baekhyun glanced down to his phone and stood up, nodding. “Yeah. Sure, I’d love to.” Anything to get his mind off Chanyeol.

---------------

Chanyeol texted back the next day.

Upon seeing Chanyeol’s name flash across the screen, Baekhyun ignored the text. Baekhyun had stayed out with Jongdae and the others all night, and he was way too tired to deal with anything that the other might say, so when his phone vibrated again, he put it in a drawer and hid himself under his blankets.

Jongdae came into his room and ignored the lack of the usual sparkle in Baekhyun’s eyes. “I have no duties today and you haven’t been doing much, so do you want to go out and just waste some time together? Who knows what we’ll do…”

Baekhyun quickly agreed, pretty much pulling Jongdae out of the house by his sleeve.

The two returned home hours later, laughing and singing wildly. Not long after returning, Jongdae left to get some ice cream that he claimed would make Baekhyun’s socks fly off. Baekhyun wasn’t sure why ice cream would affect his socks, or if he even wanted his socks to come off, but he nodded skeptically to Jongdae as he left anyway. 

Baekhyun continued singing softly as he looked around his room for his phone before finding it in a drawer.

At the sight of Chanyeol’s name and the notification of 29 new text messages, Baekhyun sighed before opening his inbox to read them.

From Chanyeol: “Byun Baek I need to tell you something.”

Baekhyun braced himself as he read the next text.

From Chanyeol: “So I visited your grave today…”

Baekhyun blinked, wordlessly flicking through his inbox as he read each individual text.

From Chanyeol: “I put down some white roses. I know they were your favorites.”

From Chanyeol: “I had some waiting for you at home with another gift after we argued that day too. I thought it’d make us better.”

From Chanyeol: “I actually wanted to visit yesterday, but I got kind of busy with Kyungsoo.”

From Chanyeol: “But anyways, I just wanted you to know I’m thinking about you.”

From Chanyeol: “… Well obviously, if I’m texting you… right?”

From Chanyeol: “I’m sorry, I’m rambling. I’m nervous. I should just get this over with, right? Not like you’re going to read it…”

From Chanyeol: “… I need to calm down. I’m wayyyy too nervous.”

From Chanyeol: “Okay, well, I need to tell you something. And I’m just going to come out with it because rambling isn’t working.”

From Chanyeol: “And I know you’re not going to get these, but it’s kind of a stress reliever or something. … I can always pretend, right?”

From Chanyeol: “Baek… I really miss you.”

From Chanyeol: “And maybe it’s safe to tell you now because I wanted to before, but I couldn’t…”

From Chanyeol: “So… here goes nothing.”

From Chanyeol: “Aieru.”

From Chanyeol: “Te amo.”

From Chanyeol: “Je t’aime.”

From Chanyeol: “Saranghaeyo.”

From Chanyeol: “Byun Baekhyun, I love you.”

From Chanyeol: “I have for years.”

From Chanyeol: “And I will love you forever.”

The door slamming and Jongdae’s boisterous laughter caught Baekhyun’s attention, forcing him to look up from the screen, turning his attention to Jongdae, who was holding a couple of tubs of ice cream.

“I got a lot from Minseok, so we can…” Jongdae’s voice trailed off as he noticed the blank look on Baekhyun’s face. “Whoa, what happened to you? Once second you’re drunk on life, and now you’re broken.”

Baekhyun stared at Jongdae blankly for a few seconds as though his brain was still trying to comprehend what was happening and trying to get his muscles to take the correct course of action for everything to progress normally. He wanted to run away. This isn’t happening; this isn’t happening. He wanted to put down his phone or throw it at the wall or just will it to burst into flames – anything that made it seem like this wasn’t happening. He wanted to avoid the conversation and awkward situation all together, but he found himself turning back to the screen to read the remaining texts with a bemused frown.

From Chanyeol: “… I wish you could tell me that you love me back.”

From Chanyeol: “I wanted to tell you. I really did. But I couldn’t. You left me before I could… Think of the days we could have spent together if you said yes…”

From Chanyeol: “But hell, I don’t think you even liked me back. That’s why I was such a coward. I’d rather keep it a secret than have you run away and never talk to me again…”

From Chanyeol: “I was scared of the rejection, so I chose to be alone. Now I wish I wasn’t.”

From Chanyeol: “… People tell me to stop texting you, but for some reason, I can’t. It just feels so right, you know…”

From Chanyeol: “I’m sorry for all the texts. I just really needed to get this off my chest. I love you Byun Baek. Never forget that.”

From Chanyeol: “I’ll wait forever for the day when you’ll see me as more than just a friend. Even if I feel like I’m waiting for something that isn’t going to happen.”

From Chanyeol: “We were supposed to be together forever right? I’m not going to break that promise.”

“That’s not good…” Jongdae’s voice from over Baekhyun’s shoulder startled him. “That’s really not good.” Jongdae took Baekhyun’s phone and shoved him onto the couch, exclaiming, “Operation Ice-Cream-Cheer-Up-614!” and started shoveling ice cream into Baekhyun’s mouth until he laughed, choked, and lashed out on Jongdae in anger from a brain freeze, but Jongdae’s laughter made him smile, even if just for a moment.

---------------

The next day, Baekhyun laid in bed all day and stared at the ceiling while his mind swirled with countless thoughts of his life.

Chanyeol’s mass of texts from the day before were stuck in his mind, and no matter what he did, they wouldn’t go away.

‘Byun Baekhyun, I love you.’

Baekhyun winced. This was not something he needed to deal with right now.

And besides... he and Chanyeol were just friends. They used to be friends. He didn’t see Chanyeol like that at all… right?

Chanyeol was that weird kid that he met one day at some playground, and eventually became really great friends with. They were nothing more. They had spent the better part of 10 years together and Baekhyun thought that he had known everything about Chanyeol that there was to know. They had too many memories for their friendship to be ruined by something like these unnecessary emotions.

Baekhyun sighed into his bed, reminiscing about old memories of his best friend when he realized that he remembers a lot about Chanyeol.

He remembers when he met Chanyeol over ten years ago, when they were eight, how much he liked ferrets.

He remembers the first time Chanyeol gave him a present not even on his birthday, but it was a sticker of a ferret, and because Chanyeol said it was one of his most treasured items, Baekhyun treasured it too (even though he didn’t like ferrets nearly as much as Chanyeol).

He remembers how squishy Chanyeol’s face looked, and how on multiple occasions Baekhyun wanted to squeeze his cheeks together and make Chanyeol say, “Chubby Bunny,” until he couldn’t resist the urge to, but Chanyeol kept laughing in the midst of it.

He remembers the anger in Chanyeol’s eyes when two boys were bullying Baekhyun on the playground. He remembers the admiration he felt when Chanyeol chased them away and helped him stand up and made him feel like a king for the rest of the day.

He remembers staring up to Chanyeol in amazement when he pretty much grew an entire foot over summer break and lost his signature chubbiness that Baekhyun had grown fond of. He remembers pouting when Chanyeol laughed down to him after getting something from a shelf Baekhyun couldn’t reach. He remembers how Chanyeol stood on top of the slide on the old playground near his house, raised his arms and shouted that he was on top of the world.

He remembers noticing Chanyeol by how he stood a head taller than everyone else in their class and how his auburn hair caught the sunlight and made it look like his head was on fire.

He remembers laughing at Chanyeol the first time his voice cracked in front of him and noticing the adorable blush on his cheeks when he playfully pushed Baekhyun away, telling him to stop.

Then he remembered the first time he heard Chanyeol say his name his deep, suave voice and when he laughed in that same deep tone at the surprised look on Baekhyun’s face.

He remembers every time he watched Chanyeol play his guitar, the way his eyes fluttered closed and the soft smile on his lips, how serene that he looked, and Baekhyun wished to make Chanyeol look that happy on a daily basis just by being around him.

He remembers the shocked look on Chanyeol’s face the first time Chanyeol successfully convinced Baekhyun to sing for him, the confidence in his voice when he made Baekhyun audition for the talent show, and the pride in Chanyeol’s eyes when Baekhyun won. Baekhyun remembers taking a single white rose from the bouquet Chanyeol gave him and playing with the petals as he lay on his bed, with a wide toothy grin on his face.

He remembers the heat in his cheeks their first year of high school together when Chanyeol stepped out of the pool in the gym. It wasn’t the first time Baekhyun had seen Chanyeol half- and dripping with pool water, but this time seemed distinctly different. He remembers staring as his eyes drank in every little detail – the way his wet swim trunks molded to the curvature of Chanyeol’s body, the way the water clung to his chest and biceps as though it didn’t want to let go, the way his damp hair fell in front of his eyes until he flipped it back with a dazzling smile in his direction, and the way Baekhyun’s heart sped up and he couldn’t avert his eyes he did so. He remembers that.

He remembers the time he sat in between Chanyeol’s legs as he played his piano and Chanyeol messed with his hair lazily, humming the melody of the song into Baekhyun’s ear. He remembers the way his chest tightened as it got harder and harder to breathe and his thoughts strayed away from the song he was playing and he focused on Chanyeol’s fingers in his hair, or Chanyeol’s soft, deep voice and his breath on his ear…

He remembered watching Chanyeol’s eyes follow a new student around as he blanked out while staring at her rather than paying attention to him and listening to their own conversations. He remembers that weird upset feeling that he couldn’t place, but he hadn’t been able to shake it for the day until he and Chanyeol went home together.

He remembers when they spent Valentine’s Day alone together, sarcastically making comments at sappy romance movies and failing at baking brownies together, which just ended in a flour fight in the middle of the kitchen. They also fed each other the brownie batter which somehow turned into throwing it at each other with their wooden spoons. He remembers seeing Chanyeol’s bright smile plastered on his chocolate covered face as he laughed, and Baekhyun thought it was the most beautiful thing he had ever seen.

He remembered lying next to Chanyeol the night before the accident, curled up in Chanyeol’s arms as the giant sleepily mumbled, “I’ll stay with you forever, Baekhyun,” and the butterflies that fluttered in his stomach at the moment. It was a moment he wished would never end. He recalled how he stayed awake after he was sure that Chanyeol fell asleep and turned in his arms to run his finger across the sleeping giant’s face, dazed by their proximity. He brushed his auburn hair back with his fingertips and ran his fingers over his soft skin. He vaguely remembers staring at his lips, wondering what they felt like, what they tasted like, or how they would fit between his own before drifting off to sleep.

He also remembers waking up to that angelic, sleeping face (and Chanyeol’s mother’s screams) the next morning and being rather grumpy about the thoughts from the night before, dismissing them as an irrational, sleep-induced delusion (when he knew deep deep deep inside that they really weren’t). He also remembered thinking of how weird it was to even have thoughts like those about his best friend, and tried to avoid him for the rest of the day so those butterflies wouldn’t come back whenever he saw Chanyeol’s face or when Chanyeol’s hands even brushed against his. He was grumpy because he simply just didn’t understand why he thought that or why Chanyeol made him feel that way.

Baekhyun sat up quickly. Hell, it’s always been about Chanyeol, hasn’t it? Baekhyun shook his head and rubbed circles around his temples. Why did it take so long to realize it? Why did it take Chanyeol telling him first for him to stop denying the thought that he could have been in love with his best friend?

Baekhyun groaned. He wasn’t sure when he fell in love with Chanyeol. Whether it was when he was a ferret crazed freak, finally got his growth spurt, or when they sang their first duet and Baekhyun realized how good they sounded together, he didn’t know. Maybe it was the first time his laugh made Baekhyun’s ears long for the sound, or his sad face made him want to hug him and never let go, or when Chanyeol would whisper in his ears and make his cheeks heat up. Maybe it was the first time they met. Maybe it was the last moment they spent together. Maybe he fell in love with him over and over again.

Baekhyun wasn’t sure when it happened. He just knew that it did, indeed, happen.

He took in a deep breath.

“I’m in love with Chanyeol.”

The sound of his sentence reaching his ears made him feel whole. He suddenly felt relaxed. He felt chains release him. He felt more lighthearted, like he had told his biggest secret aloud and no longer had any reason to hide it.

Yep… I’m definitely in love with Chanyeol.

But then a sharp pain shot through Baekhyun’s chest. And now… I won’t be able to tell him.

-------

Upon his return to the house after a long day of delivering messages, Jongdae found Baekhyun sitting at the table with his head folded down in the crook of his arm.

Jongdae sighed as he pulled out a chair next to him and let his satchel to fall to the floor. “Is there something wrong?” When he got no response, he asked softer, “Do you want to talk about it?” Baekhyun slowly shook his head. Jongdae frowned and responded, “Well we’re going to anyways.”

Baekhyun didn’t look up.

“Is it something about Chanyeol?

Baekhyun didn’t move, much to Jongdae’s annoyance. The messenger groaned. “You can talk. You can say anything you want to say. Just to get it off your mind.”

Baekhyun still showed no signs of acknowledging him, which prompted Jongdae to respond, “Or if you don’t want to talk, that’s fine. You can just sit around in misery.”

Baekhyun’s face sank further into his arms and he made a soft whimpering sound. Jongdae put his arm around Baekhyun’s shoulder and nudged him a little, saying, “Come on, Baek. Something. Just say anything. The first thing that comes to mind.”

It took a few seconds for Baekhyun to mumble softly, “It’s just weird to think that I could have been in love with him for years and not know it.”

Jongdae raised an eyebrow. “You actually like him back?”

Baekhyun stood quickly and shouted at the ceiling, catching Jongdae off guard.

“At first I thought it was weird that he liked me, but what the heck, I’ve probably liked that dude since the sixth grade oh my god, Jongdae, help me.

Jongdae blinked and frowned. “Well there’s nothing to do about it now.”

Baekhyun paced back and forth before stopping in front of the couch and flopped down, sinking into the cushions as he cried internally. “I know, that’s the problem. But how am I supposed to just sit around and watch while my best friend goes off and falls in love with someone else and ing marries them?”

Jongdae winced and whispered, “Language!” but Baekhyun ignored him as he covered his face in a pillow to muffle his groans.

A few seconds of silence passed before Baekhyun sniffed softly. Jongdae was getting tired of Baekhyun’s bipolarity.

Jongdae stood slowly and sat next to Baekhyun on the couch. He pulled Baekhyun into his lap and hugged him tightly. “Hey, hey… it’s okay. I’m here.”

Baekhyun slowly curled his arms around Jongdae’s back and leaned into his chest, whispering into the soft cloth of his shirt, “Thank you.”

Jongdae allowed a minute of silence to pass before he frowned and glanced away before asking softly, “You know, Baek, why don’t you just let go?” Baekhyun tensed up a little, prompting Jongdae to continue. “Maybe you should just forget about him and go on with your life. If it’s bothering you, maybe you should just stop.”

Baekhyun’s arms tightened a bit around Jongdae. “That thought never occurred to me before… How am I supposed to let go of someone that I’ve been holding on to for so long? Chanyeol was… Chanyeol is… everything… how am I just supposed to let go of that? I don’t know how to do that…”

Jongdae silenced and looked down to Baekhyun, not knowing how to respond.

Baekhyun sighed and mumbled, “There’s so much more I wished to do in life.”

Jongdae ran his fingers through the thin, brown strands Baekhyun’s hair and nodded slowly. “I’m sure everyone you talk to here will say the same thing.”

Baekhyun’s fingers tightened in Jongdae’s shirt. “I just wish I had more time to sort out my feelings… or at least recognize his! I never even noticed that he felt that way – I never even noticed I felt that way.” Baekhyun sniffed and allowed a couple of seconds of silence to ensue before whispering, “I’ll never even get to tell him.”

Jongdae frowned. “Life’s unfair like that.”

After a large amount of silence, Baekhyun spoke up. “I argued with him on our last day together. Over something stupid. I wish we had spent that day together instead of being mad at each other…” He paused and sighed into Jongdae’s arms. “There’s so many things I wanted to do that I can’t…” He sniffed. “I wanted to go to college with him and get into the music industry with him. We should have spent more time together doing the little things that we appreciated. We could have had more dinners together or simply just be in each other’s presence more. We were supposed to lie around on the roof and laugh at the memories in that photo album on Chanyeol’s birthday, and we didn’t even get to do that…” Baekhyun lifted his head and stared down to Jongdae. “We can’t even sit like this!”

Jongdae smiled. “You can always pretend that I’m Chanyeol.”

Baekhyun scoffed and put his head back on his shoulder. “You’re not tall or cute enough to be.”

Jongdae lifted Baekhyun’s head and stared at him in mock hurt. “You don’t think I’m cute?”

Baekhyun smiled a little. “Not as cute as Chanyeol.”

Jongdae rolled his eyes and lifted Baekhyun off his lap, opting to set him next to him again. Baekhyun looked up to Jongdae and smiled. “We can still be friends though!”

Jongdae looked down to Baekhyun, relieved to see the other smiling. “I’m good with that. Plus there’s a cute angel I’ve got my eye on already…”

Baekhyun glanced over to Jongdae with a playful smile on his lips. “Oh? Who’s the lucky angel?”

Jongdae stood and stretched before he glanced down to Baekhyun with a smile. “Not telling. But I heard a myth that if you surprise one of the angels in charge of storms enough, they sneeze lightning… or their sneezes sound like thunder or something. Wanna go prove a myth?”

Baekhyun smiled and jumped up, racing Jongdae to the door.

---------------

 

Like this story? Give it an Upvote!
Thank you!

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
pjloverj #1
Thank you so much for writing and sharing this story with us. It poked my heart, twisted it, left me a crying mess and yet I feel like t is probably something I needed to read while in grief. I try to avoid angst/death stories but it's chanbaek.....I was starting to fear where t was going but your writing made me continue. I can relate to Chanyeol so much and writing this makes tears start again.... Kudos to you and gain, thank you for writing.
after_dark #2
A lot of spelling errors in my comment but you know what i mean lol
after_dark #3
Chapter 9: SPOILER!! DON'T READ THIS IF YOU HAVEN'T READ THE STORY YET. THIS IS JIST FEEBACK FOR THE AUTHOR.
by the way this is jist feefback on what i though of the characters and story. Im not trying to take a dig at you. Youre an amazing author. I love all your stories and im literally obsessed with everything you write. Im not hating just wann make that super clear lol

I love your writting. Its really easy to follow and understand. Great idea. The way chapter was split up was great. The story was really sad i cried like baby esp whenever cy would breakdown. I cried extra hard when he tried to kiss kyungsoo omg. I had to put my phone down and compose myself. I liked that at the beginning we didint know who was writting the journal or what wad going to happen next. I was hooked and i honestly couldnt put my phone down till i finished. Took my three hours to read lol. I didnt want it to finish. You put a lot of time and it shows.


bUT I COULDNT STAND SOME CHARACTERS especially my very own biad BYUN FREAKING BAELHYUN'S CHARACTER. He was selfish. So soo selfish. And even after all he did Baek got to ERASE his memories. Thats so unfair lol. If they cant be together i feel like they should of erased both of their memories. For chanyeol even if they dont erase his love for baek i feel like they shouldve erased the time in which baekhyun was his guardian angle. If you think about it chanyeol was finally moving on with his life. He was starting to accept that baek was dead and was starting to let go. He had an amazing boyfriend/roommate who liked him alot. Who was teaching him to love again to open his heart even a little bit. Who was patient with him despite being told no mutiple times. But who ruined it? Baekhyun! All bc he was jealous and selfish. Like i wanted to rip my hair out. Between the two of them u cant deny chanyeol suffered the most and thats understandable bc he lost someone he loved. I cried more for cy. I felt soo bad for him and even after baek got his memories erased he still suffered which is depressing as

But baek was totally fine. He was in heaven he had friends . He was an angel. He got to see chanyeol everyday. He could touch him, visit him in his dreams omg. Chanyeol had no one. The love of his life was dead. I mean yeah he had his family and kaisoo but jongin was an to him when he needed him most and kyungsoo was the reason baek died lol. He only had kris who tried to understand him and baek ruined that and bc of him messing in his head and his dreams, he pushed kris away andwent back to being depressed again. Even more so than before. Like how freaking selfish can you get? I mean yeah in the end he (baek) did make a great sacrife but even that wasnt really a sacrifice. He got his memorises earsed so no more pain and suffering. He got to keep xuichen and luhan his friends. He also got a promotion. Like a big promotion. What?? Meanwhile cy still remembers everything. dae even told him not to forget. To remember baek forever. Huh?? Why??

For me the pefect ending would be if fate and destiny decided to erase their memorise, they should've both gotton their memories erased. That would've been sad but chanyeol would finally find happiness.

OR for an extreamly sad ending,

baekhyun kept his memories but got a different job. A job in which he couldnt physically see chanyeol ever again. (That would've been hella tragic.) Doesnt find love again (until he meets chanyeol again ofc)

chanyeol would keep his memories too. Doesnt ever find love again either bc he loves baek too much to let go

jongdae: gets a different job, away from baek and minseok. Gets to keep memorises

minseok: (im sorry minnie) should've had his powers taken away from him. Not only did he mess up cb AND gave his ring to baek which makes it partly his fault but he got no punishment? He doesnt even get to live with the guilt for allowing baek to get killed and ruining cb. I mean wasnt he their matchmaker? He didnt even care lol. He was a really ty friend.

Jongdae was really sweat. And he was my favorite character. He always looked out for baek, cheered him up he tried to help baek move on. This is cb story i know and i ship cb BUT if baek ended up with jongdae, and yeol ended with kris i honestly wouldn't even be mad.

Thank you for writting this story i really enjoyed it
ZeLLuu_Baek7 #4
Chapter 10: Okay so I promised myself that I will never ever read angst or tragedy again like two years ago because I am such a crybaby when it comes to Baekyeol in angsty situations (my heart breaks so many times reading like that) AND I know that this fic is from 2014... BUT today in 2018 I stumbled upon this and somehow I started to read it... EVEN THOUGH I CRIED THE WHOLE ATLANTIC AND I couldn't move for hours I don't regret a single second BECAUSE seriously this story is such a piece of art!!! Every word in this fanfiction is just perfect! Your writing style is simply amazing and you did such a fantastic job authornim! ♡
Thank you so much for creating this beautiful Chanbaek masterpiece *bows* I am truly thankfully that so wonderful stories exist! THANK YOU ♡ and I hope you have a great day~
yeoldaaa #5
This is so beautiful. Thank you.
baharex
#6
Chapter 9: Four years and I dont think I'll ever be able to forget this fic.
Happy new year author-nim.
byunnie16
#7
Chapter 9: it's been almost ..3 years(??) since i've read this from MOC ..i still can't believe even though I already know what's going to happen once i started rereading this for the nth time, I still love this like i've read this for the first time . thank you for this beautiful fanfic


till i come back again to read this someday :') maybe next year? and the next?? and the next one after that??
goldensuho
#8
Chapter 10: I had forgotten how much I loved this when I first read it. What a a beautiful, beautiful story. These swollen eyes and this awful headache after crying so hard bc of this are super worth it!
naty_kkaebsong
#9
Chapter 10: I can't believe this made me cry so much , it's unbelievably beautiful. Like every sentence just made me so emotional and I can't really say enough how much I appreciate and love this story. The anguish was real, the sadness was real but so was the happiness. The ending was really good, I think it couldn't have been better. Great writing style it's so well written. I think this story is just perfect. Thank you so much for writing this, I really appreciate your efforts. Lots of love ♡♥♡