Review 1: Princessamy : Longing For A Pulse (Octy08)

Octy's Review & Beta Shop | Closed Permanently! | Moved To R&B Shop
Please Subscribe to read the full chapter

First Impressions:

Before I say anything that might hurt anyone's feelings, let me just say that I'm an Exo stan so please don't hate on me should you feel hurt by what I'm about to say in the next few lines. I have to be honest here. When I first saw your story, I groaned. Because there are a lot- and I mean A Lot- of Exo fanfics on AFF so I kind of dreaded reading it because I've already read so many of them. I got really stereotypical and thought your story would be just like other Exo fanfics. Apart from that, I don't usually read angst because I tend to get really emotional so it took me quite a while to persuade myself to read it. But hey, this is only a first impression and first impressions usually change right? ;)

 

Title:

Remember when I said I dreaded reading your story? Well, that changed when I saw your title, 'Longing for a Pulse'. It intrigued me in a way and made me want to know more about your story. I also did a search for stories with the same title as yours but found none; which is good because a reader like me would usually ignore stories with common titles. Readers want titles that stand out from others and get readers curious about the whole story plot. And your title did just that :)

 

Description & Foreword:

In your description, you used a song format. Now here's one thing you need to know about song formats; less is more. Story descriptions should make readers curious and entice them to read the the story. Using two songs defeat the whole purpose of a description because it would give a readers a stop-and-start feel, if you know what I mean. Maybe you could pick an excerpt from both songs and merge them together? I actually tried doing it and came up with this.

 

I hadn't even spoken the words, I just let you go

My late confession, can you hear it?

I love you

I love you, so I hold back

- "Because I Miss You" by Jung Yong Hwa

- "Only Tears" by Infinite

 

I'm not saying you must change your description to that though; it's just a suggestion that I thought you could use :) 

To be honest, your foreword had more feel and was definitely better, compared to your description. Even so, there were parts where your sentences were unclear and hard to understand. At one point, you kind of lost me and I had to re-read the foreward again. But then, a particular sentence brought me back on track and I was simply mindblown by that one sentence; Every heart needs a pulse and every person needs a reason to live. I was really wowed by it, really. I just love that sentence.

 

Originality, Plot & Flow:

When it comes to originality, you definitely have it. See, I spend a lot of time reading fanfics on AFF and I have to say that your plot is definitely something I have yet to come across. Your plot is uncommon and stands out from most of the other angst stories I have read. It isn't cliche' and neither is it cringe-worthy. Okay so here's one thing about me; whenever

Please Subscribe to read the full chapter
Like this story? Give it an Upvote!
Thank you!

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
grainsofbap
#2
Chapter 16: I hope you feel better!! <3
xiumin-nimuix
#3
Hey there, sorry for the inconvenience but I will be canceling my request!
willienelson09
#4
Chapter 16: Hey, thanks for taking the time out of your busy schedule to post this. I hope the next few months go smoothly and that you'll be doing good.
jonginies #5
hey there! i'm cancelling my request bc i'm deleting my fanfic. i'm so sorry for the inconvenience. :/
Tierbanre
#6
Hi! First of all, thank you for the review. I know since I started to write my fanfic that it wasn't going to be really good. It's the first time I write a text in english, so it's really difficult to me express what I want to say xD I'm just learning to speak it and I found this a good way to start.
Tai is too vulgar, I know xDDD
I appreciate a lot your review, you helped me so much.
Anyway, I'm going to finish my fanfic, and next time I will write one in spanish (my spanish grammar is perfect, yay! xD) and then I will try to translate it.
Thank you, again!! ^.^
LoveAsAlways #7
Chapter 1: Well I hope mine can be reviewed soon x)
jonginies #8
oh, can i make some changes to my request? i'm changing it from one shot to chaptered. ^^
Mattokki
#9
Author: Mattokki
- Story Title: It's Not Me
-Story Link: http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/685695/it-s-not-me-angst-oneshot-baekhyun-chanyeol-taehyung-vbts
- Story Type (Oneshot/Chaptered): oneshot (with an epilogue at the end, does that make it a twoshot? Not sure)
- Genre: angst (with a bit a dead body in the beginning, just getting that out there)
- Characters/Pairings: V (of BTS), Byun Beakhyun (minor), Park Chanyeol (minor); no pairings
- Summary : It wasn't me.I didn't do it. Everybody seems to think that I'm a killer. But I didn't do it. Why will nobody believe me? No matter how much I scream, no matter how much I cry, no one seems to hear my voice. It wasn't me. Nobody believes me. Do you?
- Status (On--going/Completed): Completed
- Is English your first language: Yes, it is.
- Additional Notes: There's a bit of descriptive, almost gore-ish, at the beginning, and a tiny bit in the middle. Nothing too bad, but make sure whoever is reviewing it can handle that.
-Password (In the rules section): YayOcty
jonginies #10
- Author: kpopaholic121

- Story Title: Finding the Eternity in Our Love

- Story Link: http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/671840/finding-the-eternity-in-our-love-angst-mark-got7

- Story Type (Oneshot/Chaptered): Oneshot

- Genre: angst

- Characters/Pairings: Mark Tuan & Kim Nayeon (OC)

- Summary: Days... Weeks... Months... Yet, he was still at that certain place where they first met as if he was stopped in time. Time seemed to have frozen for him who can't forget and leave the past, when she left him behind all alone. After she left, he finally started to regret the things he hasn't told her, the things he wasn't able to do with her. Most of all, he regretted he wasn't able to give her good memories. Searching for her, still, he wasn't able to find her. Trying to get her back, still, it was nothing but a mere futile attempt. No matter how hard he tried, his efforts shamelessly turned into vain. Why? It's simply because she isn't here anymore...

- Status (On--going/Completed): On-going

- Is English your first language: nope, it's my second. :)

- Additional Notes: -

- Password (In the rules section): YayOcty