sujushipper⚓The Ice Princess & Her 12 Suitors

✰Mystery's Review Shop✰ || CLOSED ||

 

 

Title: The Ice Princess & Her 12 Suitors

Author: sujushipper

Characters: Park MiNa (OC), EXO


 Title:

Just by seeing the title, I can figure out the storyline. But, since it is a comedy genre, it's okay. 

Rating: 4/5

Description/Foreword:

The description of the characters should be in the foreword section and the description of the story should be in the description section and lastly, the author's note should be at the end. In my opinion, though.

For the character's part, you shouldn't reveal everything, it will just spoil the story. Revealing it slowly will spark the interests of the readers out there.

Rating: 6/10

Grammar:

"classic stories of princesses acting as the damsal in distress whilst the knight in shining armour comes to save the day, and then they live 'happy ever after'," should be "classic stories of princesses acting as the damsels in distress whilst the knight in shining armour comes to save the day; then they live 'happily ever after'."

 "resulting in you not wanting to step out of your comfort zone and be adventurous." should be "resulting you, still in your comfort zone and not be adventurous."

"Oh, yeah. Thanks. I think I best be going now, s'good seeing you, Min," should be "Oh yeah, thanks. I'll be going now. Good seeing you, Min." (This seems a bit vague because I didn't understand anything."

  "Immediately, you began tidieng up and putting it back within the box." should be "Immediately, you began tidiyng up and putting it back in the box. "

"As a princess." You should remove that. It doesn't play much in the paragraph.

By the way, you should put some punctuation marks at the end of each dialogues.

Rating: 19/25 Due to punctuation marks.

Characterization:

The characters are well explained throughout the story but Mina seems a bit too mary sue. Mina doesn't like guys ever since birth, shouldn't that be impossible? Unless some traumatic experience occured in her life. Especially the part when she told them straight that her mother died, its as if she didn't care at all. EXO is okay but the way you emphasize Chanyeol, Baekhyun and Kris was a bit off. She needs to find a suitor. She needs to meet every EXO member and evaluate them. To check who is going to be (or not) her suitor.

Rating: 3/5

Plot/Storyline:

I've read a lot of these kinds of things already. So it was predictable. Except for the third power thing though. Also, she was intrigued by Kai at the beginning. How come it was disappearing? (I was kinda shipping them. :)) )

Rating: 20/25

Writing Style:

Your writing style is okay, but what disturbs me is that you use whilst too much (my opinion). You should be careful with the commas, periods and such. Vocabulary-wise, it is okay. Italicize the sound effects.

Rating: 4/5

Originality:

I like the 'marry the one you love so that you could obtain your power'. It gives off the feeling to the readers (including me) that you placed an original feel to the story. You also put emphasis to the characters but balance it out. So that each of them gives a distinct character. Not just 'The nice ones like Chen and Xiumin'. That's too vague.

Rating: 16/20

Enjoyment:

To be honest, I was half-happy and half-sad. The fact that it was a bit cliché and Mina should have a slight spark on one member. Hehe.

Rating: 5/10


Hi there! Keep on updating and fighting!

Don't forget to credit us and comment once you have recieved your review!

-Chunkee__

Like this story? Give it an Upvote!
Thank you!
Chunkee__
[M.R.S.] We are just doing some adjustments. We are not updating, but your requests will be done anytime sooner. Thank you!

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
ChanyeolHey #1
Username:ChanyeolHey

Title of the Story: Forced Love

Link to the Story:http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/596554/forced-love-exo-kai-marriage-jongin

Story Status (Completed/In progress): In progress

Choice of reviewer: Chunkee__

p/s: I know this story have been reviewed, but i just correct some of it and need a review, again? hehe

pss: and thanks for the review! I will credit you when Imbon my computer thanks again!
AnabelleJosphine #2
Chapter 13: THANKS SO MUCH! I'm even more grateful especially because I requested late, and you actually reviewed it. I will use this review as reference for writing this story in the future, and perhaps then I will improve. Once again, thank you. This review was a great, great help. \^0^/
ChanyeolHey #3
Chapter 4: Username: ChanyeolHey

Title of the Story: Yah, I'm Your Manager

Link to the Story: https://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/559735/yah-i-m-your-manager-exo-luhan-chanyeol-lay-kris-kyungsoo-suho

Story Status (Completed/ In Progress): In Progress

Choice of reviewer: Chunkee__
Nictaeny9
#4
Chapter 10: Tks for the review!
sujushipper
#5
Chapter 7: Thanks, will credit!
itsjustnana
#6
Chapter 8: Orz I don't even know why that "ask" was there xD I must have overlooked it :/ /slaps myself/ thank you for the review <3 ^^
princessamy
#7
Chapter 5: hi, thank you for reviewing. it's alright, i know my weaknesses now. i'll fix my mistakes as soon as i can. thank you again.^^
Queensabelle
#8
Chapter 2: Username: Queensabelle

Title of the Story: Our Promise!

Link to the Story: http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/426024/our-promise-hiatus-chaerin-romance-bap-daehyun

Story Status (Completed/ In Progress): In Progress

Choice of reviewer: mysterygurl
Nictaeny9
#9
Username: Nictaeny9

Profile Link: http://www.asianfanfics.com/profile/view/488617

Title of the Story: Dark Ties

Link to the Story: http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/543164/dark-ties-jessica-romance-snsd-taeny-taeyeon-tiffany-yuri

Story Status (Completed/ In Progress): ongoing

Choice of reviewer: mysterygurl