SNSD vs. Mr.Mr.

Sorry guys, ALKP is not letting me comment on this incident so I'll just vent out my feelings here. >_<

For those who aren't aware, theres this thing going on about SM company and Winning Insight about the whole Mr.Mr. sound track.  Read here =>

http://www.allkpop.com/article/2014/03/winning-insight-releases-position-on-mrmrs-diss-song-towards-girls-generations-title-track

__________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Personally, I think both companies (notice how I didn't say group) is at fault. From MY knowledge of a kpop fan for a long time, I realized that often the singers don't have much say at times, of what song they sing, their image, and how their album turns out. Basically mostly everything is decided by a group of higher positions in that company. Therefore, I strongly hate it whenever idols get involved in these type of situation and see no point in stupid fan wars. If there's a problem, the company is responsible. Singers are merely performers, singing and behaving as they are told they should be. That is why I don't think there should be any negative feelings between Mr.Mr. and SNSD. No one is better than the other. 

In this situation, both SM and Winning Insights are at fault. Yes it's stupid how SM would use the the title track Mr.Mr. knowing full well of the new rookie group Mr.Mr. But let's face it. SM IS a cruel strict company that only cares about its marketing, business and money. This isn't old news. However, you can't deny that their methods are working somehow. I mean they are "producing" highly trained performers in the end. It's weird if they spend all their money and the outcome is a terrible off-key singer. SM company is one of the Big 3 in Korea. Why? I mean they had to start somewhere. They reached that stage because of their skilled performers earning their high reputation. To them, music IS all one big business which is the harsh reality. 

At the same time, Winning Insight is at fault since they should know better than to "diss" other singers/company. Although I do appreciate and understand what their CEO is saying. However, I think they should use this opportunity to sell their artists by showcasing their talents etc rather than using Mr.Mr. to make a point against other companies. What do they expect to happen? Social hierarchy is important in their culture. If they have problems with another company, take it to court. I don't know much about legal stuff but I'm sure there are other ways to get them justice. 

Lastly, I don't think this incident should affect either Mr.Mr. or SNSD's reputation as singers. We don't know exactly what happens behind the scenes. Obviously BOTH groups work as hard to become great singers. Instead of attacking each other, we should support them as much as possible. That's what being fans mean. Don't let the company's mistakes tarnish their chance of doing what they love- singing and performing.

 

I dunno anymore! I just REALLY hate fan wars! :(

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
Genskye
#1
Well to be honest sm isn't at fault either cuz try didnt write the song in the first place and for winning inisight well if sm release the news a while back tht snsd's title song is gonna be called mr mr and idk why they didnt do anything then but once they release it they act like they're so shocked i mean i would be frustrated too but they're also looking for attention and its so cheap... But I think neither artist are at fault
FullmetalTitan
#2
Well at least you aren't bashing the groups like some fans are. Fans should know by now that companies like SM Entertainment, don't always give the artists free will to choose the album names or the song lyrics etc. I personally blame the company, whenever this stuff happens and not the artists because most of the time, the artists are not at fault at all.

So fellow SNSD fans: Stop blaming/hating on Mr. Mr

And Mr. Mr fans stop blaming/hating SNSD

Easier said then done I suppose though ^^; I doubt some haters will listen to reason.