Of fans, immaturity and hypocrisy {updated with part 2}

 

I’m pretty sure we’ve heard of the Kai incident where he was pushed by a fan into a trash can and then left to limp to the terminal along with his managers. My source of EXO news comes from crazed, obsessed fan girls on tumblr who all claim to be “mature” and “respectful” of their idols. I’ll never hurt my idol, they said.  They need to be respected, they’re human beings! They said.

Now let me laugh for a bit at the hypocrisy of it all.

Now before you start being -hurt over what I just said, let me tell you something. I am a selective school student which ensures I have an IQ or at least grades that puts me in the 5% of the student population, I have a mother diagnosed with cancer twice which I have had to look after ever since I was a child. I’ve won writing competitions, art competitions and gotten excellent grades in my musical exams and I still simply CANNOT call myself mature. Because that would be extremely laughable. Just bring out some bubble wrap and see how immature I can truly get.

Maturity is not determined by how you dress or even how you carry yourself, it is a measure of moral, social, emotional and intellectual development. At your teen years (most kpop fans are in their pre-teens and teens according to countless surveys) it is literally impossible to be mature in all of these areas. I’m a philosophy student, I have experienced firsthand what true inconsistency of morals is and if you want to argue with me on this, bring it on because I will win (not being arrogant, it’s because I have studied this for an entire semester).

Now all of you people saying that you respect your idols and would NEVER do anything to hurt them, you may not intend to but you may hurt them indirectly. I thought I’d be composed when I went to a KPOP concert in Sydney since I’m so socially awkward, I’m practically immune to the opposite gender, but I was among all those fans screaming like a dinosaur. Or maybe even louder. Humans are unpredictable, you can’t say you wouldn’t push your idol if you saw them, because that would mean you were overestimating your own abilities to control yourself. Get off of your ing high horse.

So what? A fan pushed him, not intentionally I’m hoping and I certainly don’t endorse that kind of behaviour but please, stop using these instances as a pathetic excuse to look down on these “crazed” fan-girls. Because you just might be the same.

There’s something called herd mentality. It causes people to do things they would NEVER do on a normal day to day basis. Herd mentality is what allowed American troops to massacre the village of My Lai even thought the victims were completely innocent. Don’t overestimate yourself and don’t use these examples to look down on others.

It’s hypocrisy, pure and simple. 

 


What would true respect to an idol be? A respect of his/her privacy would probably be the greatest gift you could give them. Often, by being a fan who loves from afar, makes you the BEST kind of fans.

There was a touching story told by a famous American actor, I won’t mention who about the fan that will stay in his heart forever. He got onto a plane, in business class of course since he’s filthy rich and got allocated a seat next to a nice, blonde lady with a baby in her arms. They hit off and had a great conversation and when her baby started crying, she let him cradle her baby since it seemed to like his face. He was a little baffled, due to his mind-boggling fame and asked at the end of the flight if she knew he was. She replied that she’d followed his career form the start and was probably, his number one fan. But due to respect, and because she didn’t want to attract attention to him, she stayed quiet and treated him like a human being.

That level of self control is amazing and that respect shows how much she truly cares for his well-being. This is, what I think should be a model for us all, then our “precious” idols probably wouldn’t be stalked and pushed into trashcans. Or given menstrual pads as gifts.

Show me one video of a live performance by EXO and trust me, I will start spazzing. If they were right in front of me, I highly doubt I’d be able to stay composed. Fans, instead of shifting blame one another, let’s just try to learn from people like her.

That is all. Thank you.

 

-charmallama

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
enlightened_
#1
completely agree. i'll probably just lose my self control if i meet them but at the same time i don't ;~;

...but really, if i'm going to meet them, i'll try hard not to scream on their ears and just smile, and then my smile became so goofy i will start laughing my ___ off and they'll just look at me weirdly.

...or better yet, if i do meet them, i'm going to direct the horde of fans to the opposite way they went to OTL
panda_and_llama
#2
LOLOLOLOLOLOL i kind of agree
leohowon
#3
THIS THIS THIS THIS
SEEING ALL THOSE POSTS ON TUMBLR
IM LIKE "PLS DONT TALK SO MUCH U'D PROBABLY DO THE SAME THING TOO U NEVER KNOW"
THEY'RE LIKE "YOU'RE NOT AN EXOTIC" "YOU ARE CRAZY" BLAHBLAHBLAH
THAT FAN HERSELF MIGHT BE FEELING REALLY BAD TOO SDKJGHKJDSGH
SORRY FOR THE CAPS BUT REALLY I AGREE SO MUCH TO THIS BLOG
except the part about the privacy
yes that is the best gift
but idols should know that being an idol comes with no privacy
those shows where celebrities are surrounded by the press and barely get any space
THAT IS THE TRUE LIFE OF A CELEBRITY
u cant leave the spotlight once you're in it
they'll never leave u alone and the idols should know that it wouldn't be a smooth ride
kamisama
#4
Lol tbh I can't even be bothered caring about crazy fans anymore
I used to care, but now I can't be bothered
What's the point of getting yourself all tiled up and upset over them? Is it going to help your idols if you look down on other fans like that?
And to be honest I think I would be able to hold back from an idol if I saw them. This isn't me on my high horse, but it's just the honest truth that I get easily intimidated. When I meet people I've always wanted to meet, I tend to get all shy and ending up shying away (lmao)
And wow I wish I took philosophy as an elective last year when I had the chance. I would've enjoyed it
And yes I really don't think anyone can be mature in all those areas. Morally? Emotionally? Nope. I mean, I've always been /more/ mature than most kids my age, but by what standard do we define 'maturity' itself? Anyway I'm on my phone right now, but I have this really good post on tumblr I want to link you to.
I'll find it once I get back on my laptop C:
wishful
#5
[2/2] It was horrible that he fell, and I'm sure that even if it was a saesang, they didn't mean to intentionally hurt him. Like you said, I don't think any of us mean to hurt them, but perhaps doing so indirectly is something we have no control of. But from the fanaccounts and video I saw, this one was /bad/. Like, he fell onto his waist, and then when he tried to get up, he just /couldn't/. And then he apparently started crying and kept saying, "Noona, Noona, it hurts."

And based on the pictures of the other EXO boys that were taken when this happened, they were /pissed/.

I think that a part of it is SM's fault for not taking more safety precautions, but to me, that still doesn't get rid of the fact that it was an invasion of privacy. Sometimes it can't be helped though. I mean, when I'm trying to walk around the hallways at school, it's crowded. I really hope that no one purposely intends to shove me around (OTL.), but hey. It happens.

But a teddy bear in a camera? ;~; That's just... That's just /horrible/.

Tbh, most of the posts I've seen on tumblr aren't really bashing whoever pushed him. Most of the things I've seen are about how fans should be more careful and try not to push them around, or just feeling sorry for Kai and hoping that he feels better soon. But I really wouldn't be surprised if someone was trying to send a death threat or something to some random person that may or may not have been at the airport at all. OTL.
wishful
#6
[1/2]Ah, I definitely see where you're coming from.

I personally follow a mixture of younger EXOtics and older EXOtics (LOL. I actually feel kind of like a creep for knowing their ages) on tumblr, and I think that I was just as surprised as anyone else would be about the news. I completely agree with you when you say that there's not really such a thing as a mature fangirl: as soon as we see oppa, I think we'd all kind of die inside.

But I derno, I feel like this situation was much different.

I mean, though it sounds horrible, we hear cases like this happening all the time nowadays. Hell, ESPECIALLY with EXO. Luhan almost got trampled, Kris and Chanyeol got lost in the sea of fans, etc. But from what I heard (and this may or may not be true, idk I wasn't actually there), it was /saesangs/ that had been following them around like that. And I know that you said that we shouldn't look down on "crazed" fangirls, but I don't think that saesangs fit into that category. I honestly see them more as insane stalkers.

There were already rumors circulating about Kai having to get surgery on his waist, and I'm not sure if this was from a different bad EXO day or not, but I think that the manager had already tried telling fans that EXO was having a bad day and asked them to cut them some slack (three members of the Chinaline were having passport issues and weren't allowed into the country). And then Kai got in trouble with security, because he found out that one of the teddy bears a fan gave him had a freaking CAMERA in it. Good Lord, a /camera/.
shining_writer #7
This!

Thank you for noticing the acts of such hypocritical people. And I've learnt something from this post.