Between ShinHwaChangJo (ShinHwa fans) and B2UTIES (BEAST fans)

 

I was looking around at Tumblr when i saw this :

 

Do you still remember Yoseob has tweeted this?

 

 [TRANS]  It’s really beautiful to see Shinhwa Changjo fans at the idol competition cheering for Andy sunbaebim..It’s really amazing.. Like how our memories are special, let’s become beautiful b2uties who protects the memories of other fandoms!^^~ 

 

 

Here's The Reason Yoseob Tweeted about ShinhwaChangjo

i thought there was no problem behind this tweet until i found this fancam

 

here is the explanation/reasons behind Yoseob’s tweet:

 

  •  Please read this if you can’t understand the situation. Do you by any chance know of the group Shinhwa and its fanclub, ShinHwaChangJo (often shortened to SHCJ for convenience)? Well, their ‘official color’ is orange. Some fans of Hyunseung of B2st wanted to carry their own unique slogan, ‘Ranchogan’, to the upcoming concert, and what irritated the SHCJs was that the slogan happened to be orange. They practically attacked the fan that was in charge of making the slogan(online-wise, of course)
  • When none of that worked, one of the SHCJs decided to try something different. While the filming of ‘Idol Star Athletics Championships’ was taking place, they called over Yoseob and told him about this meaningless and childish fight between SHCJs and B2uties (probably in a way that made the SHCJs look better) and ‘politely asked’ him to make the B2uties stop
  •   Now there’re a few problems here that made the B2uties angry:
  1. The ‘Ranchogans’ are personal goods; they’re not official, and they will only be used in B2st’s concerts by a couple of Hyunseung’s fans. Other fanclubs, even the SHCJs themselves, created personal goods that use other fanclub’s ‘official color’.
  2. What they asked for was ridiculous, and the way they asked was also ill-mannered. As written above, the SHCJs attacked the B2uty that was in charge of the ‘Ranchogan’, which includes making rude remarks, stealing the her personal information, ect.
  3. The SHCJs spread rumors about B2st being anti-Japan on twitter. This was cruel because it may largely affect B2st’s Japanese fans and make them turn their backs on B2st.
  4. They crossed the line. Fights between fans are supposed to be settled by fans. Dragging the idol star himself into the fray is unheard of. Yoseob can be very sensitive and is considered to be tad more fragile than others, and so even fans usually treat him with care. And the SHCJs just had to pick Yoseob of all people to dump this mess on.

 

If you watched the video,you can see that he was totally upset(?) or maybe even disappointed or troubled..

The one who posted this on Tumblr said:

"Can you see how disoriented and troubled he looks in the video?
This video recording was shortened, but Yoseob sat there like that for about 5 minutes trying to send a tweet (encouraging B2uties not to use orange) in a manner that was as gentle as possible. He looked quite depressed for a while after that."

 

The uploader of the video is the one who explained the whole thing.

I just hope this won't happen again.Fight between fans and other fandoms should be only solved by them,the fans and not drag the idols on it.
idols didn't do any such things,and so other fans shouldn't also believed such rumors,like how Yoseob dated a girl before.

As many b2uties or people said that Yoseob is a fragile-like person out of the group,so i'm not sure 'bout this but he may be hurt really fast.

Just wanna say to all other fandoms there that don't make such a fuss like this..Just talk to the other fandoms nicely and politely so they'll treat you like it too and don't drag the idols in it..

Specially like what it said earlier this may caused the idol(s)'s career like B2ST activites in Japan.

 

([cr: b2stlytweets] for Yoseob's tweet)
([cr: estherksk@yt)] for the fancam/video and explantions)

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
Ur_lovestory #1
Orange is for Shinhwa , Yoseob do right for don use Orange.
chikchika #2
fyi, shinchangs probably is the most well-mannered fandom in korea. When black ocean happened to SNSD, shinchangs were the only fandom who kept cheering 4 them.so if SOME shinchangs did something like this then it was probably bcos SOME b2ties really crossed the line~
illias #3
+ JangRanCho (I think this is what you mean 'Ranchogan' if it's different, please correct me) actually asked the entertainment company, that Shinhwa is in, whether it is alright to use orange colour while pretending to be ShinChang. Obviously, the entertainment company said okay as they thought that it was from ShinChang. What JangRanCho fansite master did was lying.
Liveworks company tweeted that they didn't allowed it and topclass entertainment retweeted it.

The other claim was that the colour code is different thus it's alright to use. However, even though two colours look very similar, they will have different colour code. Only tiny bit difference will make two colours to have different colour code.

Also, this is not about personal goods. It's about supporting goods which they bring to concerts or events and use for supporting the singer. Personal goods for keeping at home and supporting goods that will be brought to events are different.

The only thing that ShinChang wanted was to change the colour of the supporting goods that JangRanCho had.

And are you sure that ShinChangs spread rumours? It's not only Beauties that are angry. At that time, ShinChangs were also angry and felt violated.

Between ShinChangs, there is this movement of 'manner ShinChang'. So in the end, they try not to get angry to other fandoms. So don't think that just because ShinChangs are not talking about this, only the beauties are victims. The actual victim for this was ShinChangs whose official colour was threatened. So the one that is actually wrong was JangRanCho fanpage.

If you want to say something about my comments, please leave personal message. I have done my homework of researching and as I am capable of understanding Korean, this information is obtained from Korean websites. Thank you. And I don't want to get into fight with a young girl like you.
illias #4
When you were saying about Shinchangs, you just sound like every shinchangs are behaving like that. To tell the truth, it's just small part of them that are messing with other fans. They were existing for more than 10 years. Some are married and lots of them are working in the society. So don't just say 'Shinchangs' please correct it as 'some of shinchangs'. It's just like saying 'b2uties' when it's actually only part of them that is making troubles.

I'm not Shinchang but I support Shinhwa. And to hear something like this, it's a bit upsetting. I know that b2uties were upset about it. But when you stereotypes one fandom like this, wouldn't it upset the fandom as well?

Actually, Shinchangs are quite well-known for their manners in Korea. (I'm not sure about now but at least few years ago. Some fandoms even say that they need to reflect and learn from Shinchangs. So, are you saying that Korean fandoms who said that were just stupid enough to claim that they have to learn from a ridiculous fandom?)

About the issue with the official colour. That is very sensitive thing in Korea. I have seen that lots of old fan clubs having arguments with new fan clubs as their official fan colour was similar to theirs. The official colour is like symbol and recognition for the fans. And about Shinchangs using other celeb's official colour for personal goods that are used for fan supports? Never heard of that.

p.s- I'm not sure about in English speaking fans, but in Korea, Shinhwachangjo are shortened as ShinChang.

Thank you. I hope that this would not create irritation to you. I'm just stating my own opinion and experience.
SeobiesWife #5
Guys dont worry.B2uties got it handled.(:
helloiloveys
#6
Well, he did date a girl before. And she cheated on him LOL. He revealed it during an interview :( AND WHAT THE HECK DID THEY CHOOSE TO TELL THAT TO OUR POOR SEOBBIE! DISLIKE HIM LOOKING SO TROUBLED >:( Although i like SH too, SHCJ should reflect :(