Review: Getting the Boy by: SKID_11

OSM story Reviews && Recommendation Corner [APPLY * NOW]

AFF username: SKID_11

AFF profile url: http://www.asianfanfics.com/profile/view/27959

Story Title: Getting the Boy

Story URL: http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/35066/

Genre: Humor/Romance/Drama

Chapter Length: One-shot

Main Characters && Pairings: SunHi (fictional), Onew (SHINee), Minho (SHINee), cameos - Taemin and Jonghyun (SHINee).

Rating: Not rated H.

Extra: I tried to do a twist on a cliche, so let me know if you think it was too cliche or not. :)

Reviewer: 13itt3rsw33t

 

 

Here It Goes

 

 

* Opening *

 

 

Title- 4.5/5  

 

- The title was nicely hand-picked and I thought that after reading the story, it might possibly have a double meaning behind it. Like the first is to get the boy whom I have a ctush on and the second is to get the boy who maybe was just by my side waiting for me to turn to him :3 I lurve titles that has a double meaning and different effect on it, it is soo enticing, in my part :D

 

 

Poster+Background- 4/5

 

- How much bluer this poster can get??? It is so my fave color :3 well, anyhow, nicely picked photos from each of them to form a poster. It is just that in every picture of them lies that certain side of them that is really depicted in the story itself. But oohhh, how I wish that Minho's picture was just as big as Onew's [err, never mind me] =D And also you could have added a background for this one to liven up the whole thing more than it already had. ^^

 

 

Description && Foreword- 8/10

 

- A brief description and foreword is really best for one-shot stories so as not to give the whole thing away. And for the foreword, I think that you should place it with the description since it doesn't make sense to me to have that as a foreword though.

 

 

Total: 16.5/20

 

 

* Contents *

 

 

Originality && OSM-ness- 8/10

 

- Frankly, I have read a lot of stories before and some of the scenes in here were quite the same. BUT I like your ideas and such in the story that it makes it different from them. :3

 

 

Plot- 12.5/15

 

- Seriously, I love and enjoyed the plot. How the story turns around and brings us to a new pace and makes us love the next one, I really love cute one-shots ^^

 

 

Chapter Titles- 3.5/5

 

- Well, the chapter title seems like to be a sub title for the story, I have thought at first, what's the need of it if it is a one-shot story but never mind, cause I find it amusing on the part of the girl 'coz she's really such a drama queen and is easily being drowned in her fantasies, leading her to some more dramatic sense.

 

 

Flow- 12/15

 

- This really happens to most of the one-shots that I have read: if too long, [it is either that] I like it [or I don't] since it is much more detailed [or too much boring] as a one-shot story and thus doesn't keep me hanging in some parts [and even some of them ends ends in an epic fail] | if just that length or short or so-so, the story would be written in a fast pace, almost keeping out of the needed scenes that are of importance to the story being left out. Your's falls on the positive middle kinda detailed yet fast. ^_^

 

 

Total: 36/45

 

 

* Expressions *

 

 

Characterization - 12.5/15

 

- The characterization of the SHINee members was like O.O it feels like I am seeing a different Minho, Onew, Taemin and Jjong in here, seems like they are real <3. And the OC's chara was plainly idiotic and naive, for just to go gaga over Onew and being such. XDD

 

 

Way of writing- 7.5/10

 

- It was good, understandable and but you could have added a little more details to it and it would be very much pleasing to read, since details could give you more that lets you create a much more creative scenario in our heads as readers.

 

 

Mechanics [Grammar && Spelling && etc]-  9/10

 

- The story was reader friendly, and I have to admit it to you that you really follow the advises of your reviewer [sorry if I am being too nosy but I read the review that you posted in the foreword and it really did help you to fix the grammars and the spellings and all]

 

 

Total: 29/35

 

 

Partial Total Score: 81.5/100

 

 

Bonus- 14/15

 

- I really love the story in whole~XDD can't say anything else but that..^^,

 

=^_^=

 

 

TOTAL = 95.5%

 

 

 

A

 

 

 

R E C O M M E N D E D ! ! !

 

I wow, this is probably the first that my grade for a review  reached 90+ and I would really be glad to give this one to you..^^ continue inspiring people,

God Bless and good luck! :3

Like this story? Give it an Upvote!
Thank you!

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
SeungHo97
#1
AFF username:<br />
SeungHo97<br />
<br />
AFF profile url:<br />
http://www.asianfanfics.com/profile/view/55428<;br />
<br />
Story Title:<br />
College Life<br />
<br />
Story URL:<br />
http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/80099/college-life-leeteuk-taeteuk-taeyeon<;br />
<br />
Genre:<br />
Iunno?<br />
<br />
Chapter Length:<br />
30 and still going. <br />
<br />
Main Characters && Pairings:<br />
TaeTeuk <3 And some Super Generation moments but not a lot (NO yuri or ;o)<br />
<br />
Rating: PG? Maybe PG13? There's kissing scenes but iunno ><<br />
<br />
Extra: TaeYeon doesn't like guys. LeeTeuk wants to be her friends. Feelings begin until bad ppl come along, ladeladelade.<br />
<br />
Reviewer: Anyone? xD
Eyah53 #2
AFF username: Eyah53<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
AFF profile url: http://www.asianfanfics.com/profile/view/12669<;br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
Story Title: Face the fact<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
Story URL: http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/56555/face-the-fact-one-shot-onew-shinee-you<;br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
Genre: idk....romance..maybe<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
Chapter Length: One shot<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
Main Characters && Pairings: Onew and Readers(you)<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
Rating: not rated H<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
Extra: It's always in the reader's P.O.V<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
Reviewer: 13itt3rsw33t
AlexaSujuFan #3
AFF Username : AlexaSujuFan<br />
<br />
AFF Profile URL : http://www.asianfanfics.com/profile/view/30801<;br />
<br />
Story Title : I am in love with NO OTHER beside of this GAY!!!!!!<br />
<br />
Story URL : http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/42680/i-am-in-love-with-no-other-beside-of-this-gay-comedy-romantic<;br />
<br />
Genre : Comedy, Romance<br />
<br />
Chapter length : currently 18 and ongoing<br />
<br />
Main characters/Pairings : Park Min-A (fictional), Cho Kyuhyun, Lee Donghae, Park Jungsu<br />
<br />
Rating : Not H<br />
<br />
Extra : I think none...<br />
<br />
Reviewer: 13itt3rsw33t]<br />
<br />
<br />
flyingyen
#4
Can I request for a review if there is only one chapter? I just want to know if I'm off to a good start. ^^;;
jungminian0403 #5
thanks! I'll keep that in mind! Um, should I post your review as one of my chapters?