Review: Best Absolute Perfect Warriors

Greyskies Review and Beta Shop [Open for REVIEWS ONLY]

Story Title: Best Absolute Perfect Warriors

Author: jamdii

Summary [As given by the author]: BAP Warriors has fallen down from their own game due to too many conflicts within the group. They tried to come back up but conflicts still continue to arise especially with the new recruit, Junhong.

Plot: 9/10

I haven't seen too many dance battle fics, so I found this one to be a refreshing change. However, some parts just seemed downright childish, which I will explain more in the next section.

Character Development: 8/10

I like how you explained about the OC's history with Yongguk and the other B.A.P members, as that helped to explain why they were acting they way they did. Yet at the same time, some parts just seemed too immature. I understand that Junhong is young, however Yongguk also seems to display the same childishness at times. It makes sense that yes, he's afraid of getting betrayed, but he seems to display it in a way that reminds me more of toddlers fighting rather than the anger of a 22-year-old man.

Spelling+Grammar: 7/10

I've noticed that you tend to misuse commas a lot, and insert prepositions when there aren't really any necessary. The story isn't unreadable, but as a native English speaker, it was difficult to read and understand at certain points.

Layout: 7/10

The gif background was kind of distracting while I was reading, because my eyes kept wandering to the glowing outline thing. I was also confused why you kept switching from centered text to left-justified (the latter, however, is the correct to use when writing). Some parts of the story repeated, for reasons I'm not quite sure... you may want to fix that.

Overall Opinion: 7.5/10

First off, I'm sorry for never getting around to betaing this orz

That aside, I thought this fic was alright. The plot was good, the character development was fine, but there was just something about this fic that bothered me. It might be that the writing style was a little too underdeveloped for me to really take seriously, but I'm not entirely sure. This may seem blunt, but I feel like if this plot were written by a different writer, I may have liked it more. Nevertheless, it was a good attempt made. B.A.P fans may want to give this a read, but I'm not personally a fan.

Final Grade: 77%—C+

If you want to check out this story, you can find it here.

Like this story? Give it an Upvote!
Thank you!
greyskieslatenights
[greyskies review+beta] 5/1: New review added

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
gonexx #1
can i hire a permanent beta?
illumina_dain #2
request type : review
Story title : The Grandmaster
Story Link : http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/706970/the-grandmaster-fantasy-exo-kai-luhan-sehun-kyungsoo
Short Summary : Fantasy, Action?, Supernatural.

Everyday, they walk the same path we walk
Everyday, they use the same language that we do
Everyday, they breath the same air with us
But
They have something we don't have
They use something we can't even imagine to have
They can do anything
And ...
They have lived among us for centuries
They are The Grandmaster

Sehun, Kyungsoo, Luhan, Jongin

Word count : around 5000 (per chapter, it's only 5 chapter so far, so around 25000 in total)
Joah
softmist
#4
request type [beta or review]: review~
story title: Flower Child
story link [if requesting a review]: http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/344495/flower-child-c-o-m-p-l-e-t-e-contest-romance-tragedy-flower-luhan
short summary [please include genre and characters]:

Romance, Fantasy, Tragedy; Yoonhae turns an easter lily into a boy (Luhan) and while they grew up inseparable, they grew apart when Luhan and Yoonhae hit high school. As Luhan slowly forgets to care and love Yoonhae, Yoonhae is forced to believe that Luhan hasn't forgotten his transformer.

Main: Luhan, OC Character; Side: Oh Sehun, Kim Jongin

word count [it's okay just to leave an approximate]: 23,000 - 25,000 ish words? it's like 1,500 and under per chapter
password:joaaaah
vrendezvous #5
request type [beta or review]: review
story title: Teru Teru Bozu
story link [if requesting a review]: http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/448272/teru-teru-bozu-myungsoo-romance-suzy-myungzy
short summary [please include genre and characters]:
A story about a girl who loves the rain yet craves for sunlight.

characters: Myungsoo (L) and Su Ji (Suzy)
word count [it's okay just to leave an approximate]: 4,209
password: Joah
MissyQ
#6
request type [beta or review]: Review
story title: Final Call
story link [if requesting a review]: http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/428461
short summary [please include genre and characters]: She didn't want to die knowing she couldn't tell him she loved him.

That was all she wanted.

Nothing less, nothing more.
Featuring Kai and OC.
word count [it's okay just to leave an approximate]: Exactly 3328 (Excluding A/N at the bottom)
password: Joah
douxsoleil #7
Chapter 14: Thank you for the review, I will make sure to take notes from your review. :))
douxsoleil #8
request type :review
story title:Krasivaya
story link :http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/357691/krasivaya-angst-snsd-yoona-kai-yoonkai-exoshidae
short summary :angst, romance, slice of life. Kim Jongin, Im Yoona. How a person could change drastically when she is on the brink of death.
word count :around 1000 or less
password:Joah
exothermc
#9
Chapter 13: thank you for the review! i am so honored to get an A. i'll credit once i'm on my computer.

thank you again!