The Grandmaster Review

Title 4.5/5:

Although your story isn't really developed yet (still at its exposition), I don't get the full vibe, but I understand it's still the begining. The title itself is quite original-- I understand that Luhan, Sehun, Kai, etc are the Grandmasters, if I am correct.


Description/Foreword 10/10 :

I enjoyed your Description. It gives a hint of the story, and makes readers want to keep reading. What is a Grandmaster? Are they immortal? I guess those were some of the questions that popped into my mind when reading it. It's short also, which is good; it doesn't overwhelm readers.


Characterization 20/20:

You did really well with developing the characters. Unlike most people, you did it in a very interesting way. You did really well with Sehun and Kyungsoo. Luhan also. The characters you put into your story has a lot of emotion, even the background ones. Although, some were cliche, I think you did well with their passions and their frustrations. I enjoyed how you revealed Kai through Sehun. I applaud you; sometimes, i have a hard time with characterizing my stories. 

 

Plot/Originality 19.5/20 :

I really enjoyed how you put EXO and their powers into a creative spin. I feel like not many people could, expecially with Luhan and Kai. I actually really enjoy the idea of your story.  It's unique. Also, your writing style is different (not in a bad way). It has a personal feel to it, and I like it.


Mechanics (Grammar, Spelling, Punctuation) 4/5 : 

With english as a second language, you did really well with your grammar and such more than I thought you would. Truthfully, when I see that English isn't their first language, I go easier on them. After reading your first chapter, I was surprised, so I graded more harshly. 

You aren't missing a lot of things, just some small, picky ones (sorry, I'm kinda a grammar nazi). 

You're sentence structure was a little off, which caused some dissapearing comas. Although not a big deal, it helps a lot with flow.

You also spelled some words wrong, so just be careful!


Reader's Response 5/5:

Your readers are so cute! They really enjoy the story, which is great. I can feel that they were just as intrigued as I was. Also, your interaction with your readers is great!


Overall Enjoyment 10/10:

I actually really enjoyed reading your story. It was quite interesting ( I think I emphasized enough on writing and things that I liked already).

 


Total: 73/75


Comments: Don't forget to credit! Oh, and thanks for requesting. You're story is quite nice (if you haven't noticed LOL). Also, sorry for the wait.

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
No comments yet