Haters and Lovers, get ready..

Yea...you can guess what I am going to do know.....

 

Well let me say this at the start, I am a Blackjack, 4NIA and Sone. So basically I am biased to all of them.

So if you are one of those people who wil hate those everyone for no reasonable reason. I sugest you save your time and not read this.

Their styles are very different. I know....so I'll just 'judge' the three according to 9 broad  bands according to my taste and at the end I'll tally and tell you all who, in my opinion, is the 'best' for their 2014 comeback.

So, basically this is going to be a

SNSD vs 2NE1 vs 4Minute

Mr.Mr vs Comebackhome/Happy vs Whatcha Doin

It begins now...


Style

SNSD

when I saw this:

I thought of this:

The style is very cool. I mean, chic and cool doctors and nurse. Toatlly innovative. Other than that, I was a bit sad...I mean their outfits were similar and I couldn't see their styles....I Got A Boy was so much better. I was more stylish in a sense all of them had a different style and it looked real nice!

2NE1

YG's motto: expect the unexpected.....

Cool hairstyles. I was speechless when Ifirst saw it....

How can Dara look good in everything? Their styles were unique too. Bom's feminine style and Minzy's youthful look. Totally cool.

4Minute

I couldn't recognise who was who when I fist say the teaser picture. For a moment I thought someone went to get plastic....

The clothes....totally crazy and shiny

it kinda reminded me of power rangers...

 

So the winners for style section is........

2NE1!


MV

SNSD

Another box mv....why am I not surprised...SM thing

It was crazy....in a good way..I liked it. Reminded me of BEG's Kill Bill,

except SNSD were not trying to kill each other like BEG was...

It was a bit confusing...they were operating on the guy right?

Okay, to be honest, I found it a little creepy....half the time I was wondering if they were going to kill the guy...they way the MV was structured and some of the effects were a bit uncomfortable...

Other than that it was alright.

2NE1

Outside fliming. I like MV flimed outside. Enjoying Scenery time. Hehehehe.

Happy MV was so cute. It reminded me of Hi-5.

H-A-PP-Y. like how the people in Hi-5 would do...adorable.

Come Back Home...very futuristic and sophisticated...hmm....remeinded me of Tron....

4Minute

Box mv....Cube does that too.....

The MV was so cute and funny.

Gayoon slapped the girl's I was like O.o...so funny...

then there was Sohyun who was acting like some doll...adorable

The side dancers coustumes were so cute...tutus....aigoo

So crazy...me like crazy MVs

So the winners for MV section is........

4Minute!


Dance

SNSD

One word: Daebak

Interesting formations...I was really impressed

The 'signature chorus' movement was so cool. Really! I was like "Whoa. So cool." I actually went to learn it and whenever I listen to that song I will do it and people will give me weird looks.

Hyo...she dances really really well. Kya~~~~

2NE1

The 'dance' was fine.....

Well YG was never a fan of dance so nothing much to say about it...

4Minute

Random style and very cute dance. Nice to watch.

So the winners for Dance section is........

SNSD!


Lyrics

SNSD

A song about a guy whom they want to have...well the lyrics are meaningful, but I think SNSD is getting a bit too old for these kinda of things. Maybe they should try out more mature songs with deeper meanings.  It will suit them more as they are now in thir mid-twenties already.

2NE1

Love song, a bit diiferent from SNSD's...

their's is more of a inner deeper meaning

for Happy its more of sacrificing your happiness for the other person's happiness

while Come Back Home is trying to say that people are addicted to their electronic devices and forgetting their loved ones.

4Minute

They are really bored. Basically they are bored. Very bored there's nothing on tv and they want to play with people.Nothing deep. Youthful song .If its just Hyuna and Sohyun its not so bad...Gayoon , Jihyun and Jiyoon are 24...it doesn't suit them...I liked Volume Up and Is it poppin would suit them more.

So the winners for Lyrics section is........

2NE1!


Catchy Tune

SNSD

the songs overall feel is nice but the flow seems a bit disturbed at times...

2NE1

Come Back Home's tune is a bit unusal..

Happy's tune is very cute eand child-like

4Minute

super cute and catchy...

La la la la la la

so cute

So the winners for Catchy Tune section is........

4Minute!


Title

SNSD

Overused...Mr Taxi by SNSD themselves, Mr by Kara...

Some rookie group got bashed for having the name Mr Mr...

2NE1

Happy was ironic....

just like Big Bang's Love Song....Taeyang and GD were very passionately hating love songs...

Effective title!

4Minute

Whatcha Doin? Doesn't it remind you of the disney channel show:

So the winners for Title section is........

2NE1!


Catchy Tune

SNSD

the songs overall feel is nice but the flow seems a bit disturbed at times...

2NE1

Come Back Home's tune is a bit unusal..

Happy's tune is very cute eand child-like

4Minute

super cute and catchy...

La la la la la la

so cute

So the winners for Catchy Tune section is........

4Minute!


Allocation of Lines and Screen Time

SNSD

TTS focus?

Any newbie would have though only Taeyeon, Tiffany and Seohyun were the only people in SNSD and the rest were backups...

Okay, Sunny and Jessica had a considerable amount of lines too..but TTS focus...is SM saying the others can't sing?

Give the others more lines!

The screen times allocation was okay. I hardly saw Hyo and Sooyoung in this MV...but it must be hard to give everyone enough screen time...the song was short and there are nine of them...

2NE1

Dara got more lines! YAY!

CL, too much screen time...

I want to see Bom and Minzy more.

 

4Minute

Gayoon, as usual, too many lines.

Hyuna, as usual, too much screen time.

But I must say its a great improvemnet compared to before.

At least now Jihyun and Sohyun can be seen and heard more....

 

So the winners for Screentime and Lines allocation section is........

SNSD and 4Minute respectively!


Satisfaction of live performances 

SNSD

No improvement no deprovement. Keep it up! But every time I look at Taeyeon I feel sad...

2NE1

Many improvements in their performances esp Minzy

She seems to be more confident now, may cos of her PS? Well she does look better now.

4Minute

3 songs? Awesome! A fun and cheerful stage!

 

So the winner for Satisfaction of Live performance  section is........

2NE1!



SNSD - 2

2NE1 - 4

4Minute - 3

The Queen is 2NE1!

It would have been really daebak if miss A had cameback as well.

The Battle of the Big 4

...kekekeke....there' s gonna be so much action in the fandoms...muhahahahaha

Do post your views below!

Haters...hate all you want as well, I don't care...its my opinion. Its a free world. Deal with it.

 

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
102xxx #1
Nice review of the three comebacks. But really, there's no need to say that 'the queen is 2ne1'. No one is the queen in kpop. Rather than saying 'queen' you should say 'leaders'. Just sayin'
laughter
#2
for the dance,
i don't really agree with snsd winning. in fact, to be honest, i don't have anyone to pick for the dance.
SNSD's dance is alright. but not too much of a biggie. it didn't really give me the strong impact, most especially when it comes to stage performance. to be honest, the chorus dance really made me bang my head against the table.

for the lyrics section,
i agree with your reviews. yg, in my opinion, are great when it comes to composition. they have their own style and i love yg for that.
for sm, no offense, but i am somehow disappointed. when i hear the korean lyrics, it was damn catchy. but when, for some reason, i search their english translation, i face palm here and there. they aren't good at composing, not enough meaning, and are just cliché/mainstream love songs for teens and/or adults.

overall, i agree with everything,
and to sum things up about the companies.... i am slowly leaving the sm family. seriously. :/
laughter
#3
im a fan of all the three, but to be honest, snsd is disappointing me now...
i agree with 2ne1, they should tot’s win! 4minute is also cool, but rooting for 2ne1!
yg sure knows how to surprise us with comebacks!
Wonachan
#4
Wow...you wrote so long...I am a fan of none...so yeah...read for fun