Hi, guys, I just wanted to ask you a quick question. so i want you to tell me if this sound plausible or really forced:

two friends are really close- one is a bit sensitive and feeling while the other is kind of like, nonchalant and indifferent about emotions. the second one begins to fall for the first one andis really worried about it,  but he eventually reasons that they're jst friends, and moves on. his friend likes him, though. But then the second guy moves out of town and begins to like his friend again, but this time he just thinks the first one is simply making him feel weird, and it will pass eventually. He moves on again, despite having had conflicting feelings for the first friends bfore. 

So, does that sound like, humanly possible, or do you think I'm just twisting stuff to make the romance one-sided? my friends often say im kind of emotionless and i feel like i'd do this, but i'm not sure if readers would accept the way friend 2 keeps brushing off his feelings and acting like a . 

What do you think?