"But to me, the Kris situation and the Luhan situation are not the same.

For one thing, Kris left basically minutes before the start of their Lost Planet tour, causing SM to scramble to rearrange the song line up, the videos that play in the back during songs, and the choreography for each song.”

Are you serious right now? Their situations are the same. they both left, its the same. Yeah Kris left before TLP concert, but guess what, SM chose to redo everything and make it seem like he was never apart of the group. SM could have kept everything as planned, from the videos, to the choreo, kinda like how 2PM did when they first performed after Jay Park left and they kept his spot in the dance open. It didnt diminish the quality of the performance at all, in fact it made it more touching because of it. But no, SM got butthurt and wanted to delete Yifans entire existence from the fans’ minds. Thats on them.

" Second, Luhan was sent to the hospital about a month ago for insomnia-related migraines, hallucinations, and fainting.”

WHAT THE DO YOU CALL YIFAN GOING TO CANADA FOR A COUPLE MONTHS BEFORE HE LEFT FOR GOOD????? JUST WHAT EXACTLY DO YOU THINK HE WAS DOING THERE PRACTICING??? NO! HE WAS RESTING AND TRYING TO GET BETTER TOO! JUST BECAUSE HE DIDNT POST ON TWITTER THAT HE WAS GOING TO A HOSPITAL OR SOMETHING DONT MEAN HIS BODY WASNT JUST AS OVERWORKED AS LU HANS!

“Now there were some sickness rumors going around when Kris left too, but they’re hard to believe considering “not feeling well” is every entertainment companies go-to excuse for misbehaving members, followed closely by “returning to school.””

So we can believe someone is sick only when they post about it on the internet????? Do you need to see Kris pass out in the street to believe he’s sick if he doesnt announce it to his followers???? outta here

“Finally, Luhan seems to have the other members’ blessings.”

Maybe they supported Kris too but was silenced by SM. Maybe they support Lu Han because they all plan on leaving too. Who knows. No one but them thats who. You cant say is different just because of some posts online. Did it ever occur to you that the other members would have put supportive messages to Kris as well had it not been for SM trying to control the situation? Cuz lets not forget that Tao uses an iPhone but all of a sudden posted negative things about Yifan using an Android or something. Never have I seen Tao even holding an Android phone, and he always has his phone on him, but he suddenly needed to use someone else’s to post on his own account???? dont add up. And I know for a fact, from an interview I saw during the MAMA era, where Yifan was explaining how the interviewer had to send over the questions they wanted to ask ahead of time so that management could pick out the ones the boys would answer and prepare the answers for them. They were even recorded holding packets of papers practicing their answers. SM loves to control the images of their artists and you think they wont go so low as to control what the boys put online during a scandal like that???

“clearly Luhan discussed this with the rest of the band before making his decision.”

Its easy to discuss leaving when someone else already cleared a path and showed you how. Maybe Yifan did or did not discuss this with the others, only they know for sure. But its also hard to discuss leaving when your manager is always around and in your business as stated by Lu Han himself.