Comments: Beautifully Imperfect

← Back to story

All Comments (556)

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
vitaamor
#1
Chapter 9: parents love are weird.hahhaaha.gotta admit that.mrs kang is nice nuff to not scold or nagged irene at her behavior but advice her nicely instead
_bittersmile #2
Chapter 9: I hope irene and her father will have a nice conversation, and he finally accept seulgi as irene's girlfriend.. Anyway i love this chapter because somehow i kinda relate to it hahaah keep up the good work author-nim!
billianette #3
Chapter 9: seulho is so cute omg
pinkishyellow #4
Chapter 9: Author-nim the story is amazing so far and it would be ashame if itll end soon. Atleast make more fluffs for us loyal readers ^_^
deer_maomao #5
Chapter 9: oh my ... you dont know how much i love this storyyyy >_< ♥♥♥
thankyou for updating..
i didnt know what to say, im so happy RN lol
taefany18 #6
Wow! I love this kind of story. Thank you for updating! ^^
TaeRene #7
Chapter 9: I love it. Parents
alyciaheart
#8
Chapter 9: if you end this story, make new seulrene story than hehee
about the parent thing, that very wise of you. love it ♥♥
assej7IM #9
Chapter 9: owww owww owwww that's it yow that's it hahahaha. I've waited for you to update this story author nim and the wait is worth it hahahaha gooood seulrene is lifeeeee
Momoswifey
#10
Chapter 9: Waaa its ending soon! ;-; i really love your story, cant wait for the last chapters :D
TakuyaKen
#11
Yeah parents care for us in a different ways
stupidvillain #12
Chapter 8: Update author
Momoswifey
#13
Chapter 8: Why the did i tear up when Irene poured out her feelings to her parents? I guess I feel the same. Anyways, akajshsgskl Seulgi's father is goals theyre so cute hahaha. Cant wait for the next chap. fighting!
minimumcats #14
Chapter 8: Ahh that kind of parents..
LeaTea
#15
Chapter 8: I THOUGHT SHE WAS ABOUT TO GET HIT BY A CAR OR SMTH THANK THE LORD
vitaamor
#16
Chapter 8: Lol seulgi conversation with her brother tho.hahaha.how i wish i had a dad like seulgi's.hes a nice man a real family man.i hope irene wont bottle up her feeling and talk it out with seulgi
vitaamor
#17
Chapter 8: Lol seulgi conversation with her brother tho.hahaha.how i wish i had a dad like seulgi's.hes a nice man a real family man.i hope irene wont bottle up her feeling and talk it out with seulgi
TakuyaKen
#18
Doubt that's a phase
assej7IM #19
Chapter 8: Crying in the corner, don't know why hahaha I get too touched at the conversation of seulgi unnie and her father and I got really hurt when irene unnie says what she feels to her parents and getting nothing from them damn it hurts me so much, irene unnie's parents not giving here any s is just deeeym she is their daughter for gods sake why they can't see all the efforts irene unnie did.
vousmevoyeznini #20
Chapter 8: Whats on this day and the overflowing feels for seulrene fanfics? Omg. Seulgi-Mr.kang parts really touched me and Irene-Bae family. T.T
Kazama_YulSic
#21
Chapter 8: irene will fit the submissive one
Momoswifey
#22
Chapter 7: ohmgggggg im crying why must you give us cliffhanger T___T

well it's okay and we'll patiently wait for it. fighting!!!!!!
kxngsxxlgx #23
Chapter 7: Irene is the submissive one pls and thAnK u sobs
chomi5ever #24
Chapter 7: IRENE SHOULD BE THE SUBMISSIVE ONE PLS :---(((
Tictacseol #25
Chapter 6: this chapter is so so so so cheesy and cute skshiflfjd im a new reader of this fic, your fic, and im really loving it.
-IceWing- #26
Chapter 7: Seulgi bear should be the submissive one :)
Great job author-nim, love the story! <3
^^
fizpizboomz #27
Chapter 7: They can take turns being submissive :D
vousmevoyeznini #28
Chapter 7: New reader here but irene as sub? Reason is, i want her to be more surprised of seulgiii
linyu89 #29
Chapter 7: i wan irene to be the submissive one.. since she's the one with "more years of experience" than seulgi..
and i feel she's more like a leader in the story (i don't know why though.. lol) so she should be leading the innocent seulgi..
deer_maomao #30
Chapter 7: i hope that mrs.kang wont saparate them :(
please be happy~

oh i think that seulgi who should be the 'submmisive' one lol
yurinmyyul #31
Chapter 7: I miss Dom-seulgi :---)
minimumcats #32
Chapter 7: This chapter was so beautiful I feel like crying ;-;
Yerimie
#33
Chapter 7: I absolutely LOVE this story. I hope you make more stories like this (JoyRi perhaps? lol) I think Kang eomma won't be mad maybe because Kang eomma figured it out and she's just waiting for the moment Ddeulgi will come out? At first I thought Irene was the perfect person to be submissive since she portrays a 'feminine' character especially in the SeulRene Be Natural dance practice but now I think Seulgi should be the submissive one since she's new with the gay/biual thing but its up to you author-nim.

Authornim do you have Twitter? I would like to follow you on twitter lol haha. I'm rambling so much I'm sorry TT Author-nim fighting~
MenaMarco
#34
Chapter 7: Both being equally submissive sounds good hehe
lazytruffle
#35
Chapter 7: waaaaa that ending!so is kang eomma gonna be mad(seems the opposite lol idk anymore just update the next chap already haha jk)

and irene should be the submissive one not because it has been seulgi in almost every seulrene fics but the fact that irene knows more and longer about the "uality" thing seulgi should learn a lot from her, but there are also some loopholes on that fact lol anyways i think I'm already talking too much. 'til then authornim great job as always!see you next time!
Kang-Baechu22 #36
Chapter 7: I want Baechu to be the submissive one!!!
choomtabi02 #37
Chapter 7: Seulgi should be the submissive one!! I'm kinda tired of Irene always being the submissive one and plus it makes sense in your story since she's so new with being gay and all while Irene alrdy had yrs to figure it out. Thanks for the great update!!!! I love it have a great week!
patotie #38
Chapter 7: I want to cry because of their sweetness! I love everything about this, the confession, the kiss, the skinship and even when they were caught kissing! Lmao! I just hope that everything will be okay and the people around them will accept them! <3
sseulrene #39
Chapter 7: i have a feeling it'll be fine because seulgi's mom is so understanding...... right??? please tell me my feeling is right LMAO
LeaTea
#40
Chapter 7: CLIFFHANGER NOOOOOOOOOOOK
seulreneislife #41
Chapter 7: I WANT TO UPVOTE THIS AGAIN AND AGAIN!!!♥
i think it will be cute if irene is the submissive...
vitaamor
#42
Chapter 7: Thank you so much for updating.im sooooo glad that they both talk it out about their so called relationship.now that they're dating i hope they will complete each other.but damn will it be ok for them?well since mrs kang saw them,and all of this time seulgi is a good student,i dun want mr n mrs kang think irene is a bad i influence.as for your questions,i personally think there's shouldnt be a 'man' in a girlx girl relationship.im sorry but for me when its yuri cp i only thought of beautiful things.sure there will be one of the cp that tops.but its depend on d relationship.bear in mind that relationship is a two ways communication.it will only works if d cp talk about their dissatisfaction,acknowledge their flaw and try to improve.
_Lazyprincess #43
Chapter 7: It's at time like this I wish Seulgi would be more popular and not the least popular member ;__; Once again she will be given a role who is not her because Irene stans only want to see her as a princess when Irene is just like a copy of Taeyeon (and all Irene fans promote it).
I thought I finally found a fic, who will not go on that sense but sigh. It will really never happen.
BaePolarBear
#44
Chapter 7: Submissive irene is sweet
Valen553
#45
Chapter 7: I think irene unnie should be the submissive one

i really like your story authornim
assej7IM #46
Chapter 7: irene unnie be the submissive one hahaha cause I think seulgi unnie is the one who wears the ahhm pants in this relationship hahaha. I was laughing and grinning throughout the chapter haha seems like Irene unnie didn't want to believe seulgi unnie e? haha I found them cute here haha and that cliffhanger, author nim better make it a good sign or else T^T I'll hate you, lol kidding please no "disagreeing parents" something like that haha
santa_ilhoon #47
Chapter 7: "Irene darts his tongue out-" I spot a mistake authornim! But it's okay, don't overdo yourself too much! (Tho I honestly want to beg for more updates lol)

I love how this is going. When I saw an update of this fic I almost screamed bcs this fic is one of my fave eVER! Keep going, authornim and my best wishes to you. ♡ Oh and the submissive one? I think it should be Seulgi, but idk how the others will vote so I'll just say mine first hehehe. I love you!
Heartbreak
#48
Chapter 7: Chapter 7: I really love this story, I have a hard time to believe english is not your first language, you write so much better than some english natives !

There a little mistake in this chapter though unnie is how a girl call an older girl, when a boy call an older guy it's noona !

About the submissive one, in gxg relation there actually no top/bottom (a mistake that 90% of the author there are doing). But to me Seulgi is the shy one, I guess the submissive one in a way.
Seulgi (in reality) is shy, let everyone do what they want (In Korea, there no way an older girl would let someone younger than her to push her or more like Joy do it), she never try to be in the spotlight, she always hide near Wendy or JooHyun.
JooHyun is shy too but I believe she is shy only on the early days she meet someone. I had the chance to see the girls irl (lived in Korea till December and for many years) and the image I have to JooHyun is someone very happy and bubbly lol. Also she is a ert, always passing hand on the rv girls lololol).

To my eyes, Seulgi is the shy one and JooHyun is the outgoing ones.


Most Seulrene fics never portrait Seulgi as anything too deep (I'm pretty sure it's because they are all Irene biased) and I do found it sad. Just like how 95% of the fic on aff believe that when lesbian make love there one that have to be the "man" and only one get pleasured. Lesbian love making is absolute beautiful and nothing like heteroual and gay . Both pleasure them self at the same time (or return the favor) and it's mostly about caressing and kissing and touching.
I don't know why people here white lesbian love/ like this.

You are doing an awesome job, really love it !
Highseul
#49
Chapter 7: Have you seen RV's previews today author-nim? You'll surely your pants when you see Seulgi, she's so freaking handsome, i swear!

I love Kang oppa ~
msdo09 #50
Chapter 7: Lovely as always <3 Hm, I'm not really sure who could be the more submissive one, I think they work best as equals (which I also think is what fits them best considering their personalities irl) and I like it better than the active Seulgi - passive Irene couple that I often find on AFF. If I had to choose I guess I'd still go with that though, since I usually see Irene as more of a frail girl and Seulgi the protective one that cares for her? Something like that but idk, it confuses me too aghhh

And yes, OOTN was wonderful, I love them all but Seulgi is too much for my poor heart <3 <3 <3
SunnyHorizon #51
Chapter 7: Beautiful fic u got there but in korean unnie is for younger girls to say and noona is for younger boys to say to an older girls or older siblings ^^
TakuyaKen
#52
You write a story that is good and different, it happens in real life I think?
TakuyaKen
#53
You write a story that is good and different, it happens in real life I think?
htc1onemax #54
please update some more
seulreneislife #55
Chapter 6: OH MY GOD!!!I DON'T WANT THIS TO END!!!(the capital letters give justice to my desperation.lol)

You should write more fluffy seulrene!
You're a great writer♥♥♥

Btw,your english is just right^^
minimumcats #56
Chapter 6: AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAH SO BEAUTIFULLL
aicatibog #57
Chapter 6: wahhh the first kiss was perfect! Seulgi and the others were so nice, helping Irene get out of that nasty mess. I really love how this story is being paced; you're doing an awesome job!
ISPEISU-DANDY #58
Chapter 6: Author nim JJANG!!! OMGGG this- this chapter and another fanfic and the instagram seulrene vid .S M.E. U.P.
LeaTea
#59
Chapter 6: OMG I LOVED THIS CHAP SO MUCH TY FOR BEING SUCH A GOOD AUTHOR EVEN THO I SENSE SOME ANGST BUT RN THAT IS OK W ME
adktyot9 #60
Chapter 6: Aww just came across this piece of treasure and i'm absolutely in love with it! Please write more Seulrene authornim!
mikito
#61
Chapter 6: I have been too busy with work this is a really nice while on my way home. Please let irene and seulgi be happy now. Happy exploring their new found feelings. Thanks! :)
msdo09 #62
Chapter 6: You just made my day with the update, this chapter and the entire story is just wonderful <3
lazytruffle
#63
Chapter 6: they are a true definition of squad goals lol and the last part is too agdgskldhdgagskdldhahs i want to hug you authornim!!
twentyforty3
#64
Chapter 6: Ahhhhhhh i love you too author-nim!!!!!!!
patotie #65
Chapter 6: WHAT THE HELL! MY HEART IS FLUTTERING AND MY EYES TURNED HEART-EYE EMOJI!!! I'm crying... this is so beautiful! Seulgi and the girls's effort just to clean Irene's name is such a friendship goals. And the freaking kiss oh god seulrene!!! I love you, author-nim! <3
patotie #66
Chapter 6: WHAT THE HELL! MY HEART IS FLUTTERING AND MY EYES TURNED HEART-EYE EMOJI!!! I'm crying... this is so beautiful! Seulgi and the girls's effort just to clean Irene's name is such a friendship goals. And the freaking kiss oh god seulrene!!! I love you, author-nim! <3
HoneyClaire #67
Chapter 6: i'm in love with u too author-nim for making this story xD !
deer_maomao #68
Chapter 6: im in love with this story of yours~
alyciaheart
#69
Chapter 6: glad they can solve irene problem.. go seulrene go
vitaamor
#70
Chapter 6: Im having a bad day and ur update save me big time.woooho.i love their friendship.tho irene parents didnt show it.they probably tried to protect irene by switching school.
snsdfangirl09 #71
Chapter 6: OMG. OMG. OMG. I was having a bad day, but your update just made it a whole lot better. Thank you, author-nim! I'm looking forward to the next chapter. :)
TakuyaKen
#72
Chapter 6: Pure love eh?
assej7IM #73
Chapter 5: Hahahaha the meeting of seulstal though I don't know but I find it funny and cool hahahaha sooooo our soojung unnie is the saviour here e hahahahaha I found soojung unnie really cool here when she said that she was the one who saw the scene and I was imagining her talking seriously wooooow and the last part though when irene unnie and seulgi unnie hug each other I feel the uhhhm love? hahahahahaha
assej7IM #74
Aigoo I got drown for a moment to irene unnie's eyes. Now I know how it feels hahaha
kimyurah #75
Chapter 5: This is so adorable, i can't wait to see how the story continues, keep up the good work!!
Hwaiting!
Frenemies #76
Chapter 5: This is so beautiful and soojung is awesome too!
JennaMickaela
#77
Omg this is so awesome!! Can't wait for the future updates...
ISPEISU-DANDY #78
Chapter 5: This is the first book I've read that has kryber XD DAEBAK~!!!
ISPEISU-DANDY #79
Chapter 5: Author nim JJANG~!!! I'll wait patiently for the next chapter~! This book is so good. Can't wait for the romansu to begin XD
danshin19
#80
Chapter 5: OMO OMO I LOVE THE PROGRESS.

did Soojung almost blurt out that Irene swings that way? Lmao I honestly love Seulstal's interaction a tad bit too much here. Hope u update soon author, thanks! :)))))
kangsojung #81
Chapter 5: I am glad you update this fic it been a while since you update and waiting is never easy for me.hope you update more frequently from now on thank for the good work fighting (b.t.w i really like hugs too
aicatibog #82
Chapter 5: Ah Soojung's dating Amber! For some reason I really like side couples in stories I don't know why. Anyways, the story is moving along so well and I can't wait for the next chapter. Keep up the good work author!
shyluv87
#83
Chapter 5: Cool Soojung...being a helper.
Awwwww Wendy and others tried to defend Irene, sweet~
pinkishyellow #84
Chapter 5: OMG my poor seulrene heart :') YOU'RE THE BEST WRITER-NIM!!!
kimchi0103
#85
Chapter 5: THIS FIC IS REALLY REALLY REALLY GREAT! I love this kind of fic, not kidding. The way they fits in each other is really sweet KYAAA And yes, hug is the best IKR LOL I guess Irene is gay from the beginning, right? Please be okay now huhuhuhu IM REALLY A SEULRENE TRASH AND STORY LIKE THIS TOUCHED MY SOUL THANKS AUTHOR <3
minimumcats #86
Chapter 5: huhuhuhu I'm usually a patient reader, but I can't with this fanfic TT-TT
patotie #87
Chapter 5: Seulgi is smart but she's oblivious to the people around her. I'm kinda disappointed that she didn't contact Irene for days to comfort her and it was even Irene who went to her house. But anyway, she made an effort to know the truth and clean Irene's name, that's sweet. <3 and oh... Soojung almost spilled the beans, I hope Bae is gay for Seulgi hahaha!
MenaMarco
#88
Chapter 5: I've been thinking about this fic to update all day long ytd and it finally did, today !
Arghhh thank you author-nim :D !
deer_maomao #89
Chapter 5: oh myyyyy... this chapter makes me sad and also happy(?)
rosiebeau
#90
Chapter 5: “Anyway, aside from the fact and everything, I’m personally very positive that Irene will never make a move on the teacher because she—“ Soojung pauses abruptly as as if she’s just being hit by a realization.
 
“Because she…?” Seulgi tilts her head, waiting for the continuation of the speech.


BECAUSE SHE'S GAY.

actually for you,Gay for you lmao okno

All hail my Delusional seulrene feels
alyciaheart
#91
Chapter 5: yeah i love hug its comporting.
nice update.. love it love it
choomtabi02 #92
Chapter 5: Awwwww I love the end part. Thank you for the update!and the fluff!! Take care!