Le Critique
Description
-May I never grow too old to treasure “once upon a time”-
- A Review Shop by seonmin97, guitardrums and a friend, Chrystal.
- We are all capable of giving well-written reviews for we’re all Literature students, so don’t worry.
- Our reviews are honest, unbiased and sincere. We will not criticize your fanfiction for childish or stupid reasons (e.g not liking the boy/girl band you wrote about), so don’t worry.
- We accept all genres, ratings and length (e.g one-shot, chaptered, drabble, etc.) HOWEVER! Please refer to the RULES for further details.
THE NOTE:
We believe that in order for one to improve, one should seek advice and opinions, but to also form his/her own opinion as well. So it is okay if you don’t agree with the review we’ve given to you. After all, it is just an opinion. But please do take the advice we give you and at least have some courtesy to accept it graciously; we’d appreciate that a lot. After all, we did put effort in it and did it seriously and properly.
Foreword
RULES
-
Please do not bash us if you are unsatisfied with your review. It is just an opinion and some harmless advice. Please keep calm.
-
Please do not rush us, as we do have other priorities as well. But we will try to finish your review as soon as possible.
-
I’m sorry, but NO YURI FICS.
-
We’ll appreciate it if you’ll post the review on your fic, or at least the link to your review.
-
It’s okay to apply to other review shops as well, it’s not like it’s a crime or anything. The more reviews the more you can improve and learn about your strong and weak points.
-
Please remember to fill in the form correctly and completely.
-
Now that you’ve finished reading the RULES, move on to the instructions then!
INSTRUCTIONS
-
Every request is categorised by its MOST PROMINENT GENRE. So you’ll have to choose only one genre that you think your fic fits under.
-
These are the Divisions.
Division 1: Comedy, Adventure, Fluff, Crack, Fantasy
Division 2: Crime, Drama, Romance, Mystery, Action
Division 3: Angst, Hurt/Comfort, Tragedy, Spiritual
Division 4: Others (please state what it is.)
-
After you’ve decided which Division your fic is under, post your request in the comments section in this format:
Author:
Title:
Summary:
Rating:
Division+Genre:
Link:
Other add-ins:
-
*Time needed to write a review:
<7000words: 1 to 1.5 weeks
>7000words but <14000words: 2-3 weeks
>14000words but <30000words: 3-4 weeks
>30000words but <60000words: 4-5 weeks
See where this is going?
OR
One-shot: 1 day to 1.5 weeks
<10 chapters: 1-2.5 weeks
20-30 chapters: 1-3 weeks
>30 chapters: It’ll take a while.
*May vary, depends on the demand and sorts.
THE RUBRICS
Title (10%): Is it an attention-grabber? Is it unique or uncommon?
Summary/Forward (10%): Is it impactful? Does it make a reader interested in your fic, to read on?
*Image/Poster (10%): Does it grab the reader’s attention?
Plot Line (45%): Is it interesting? Unique? Unpredictable? Well-written?
English (25%): Your grammar, spelling and especially vocabulary. A good fic not only needs a good plot, it needs to be written beautifully and properly.
*If you do not have an image/poster, that part will not be counted. Hence, you’ll be graded out of 90 marks instead.
Now that you're done reading, go ahead, fill up the form and we'll inform you once we receive it :)
Comments