rubric

h u g s & k i s s e s // review shop // just opened & accepting requests
 Hug & Kisses
o6eF0OA.png
vimij9Z.png
Xckfi7A.png
☓ Rubric
 

This is an idea of how I mark stories but it's not exact sot his is just an idea and can vary depending on story. Notes it's a rough guideline. Refer to this if you have problems with your mark.

----------------------------------------------------------------------

Title- /5

-Originality, and creativeness

-Is there a connection with the story?

Interesting and has an aspect of curiosity

Can it be improved?

Foreword- /15

Does it give too much away?

Is it interesting?

Do you hook the reader on?

Does it drag?

Is it set out neatly......first impressions are always important?

Does it portray your story?

Are there miss conceptions?

Characters -/30

Are they interesting and developed characters?

Are there contradicting ideas?

Does the character have an impact to the story?

Is the character introduced to the reader?

Are they a turnoff to the story?

Do they reflect the idols in real life or are they are stereotypes of them on shows?

Are they relatable?

Plot -/20

Do the reader knows about the setting and does is the setting relating back to the time period it is in?

Is the context correct?

Do you stick with your plot?

Is it believable?

Are there plot twist?

Is conflict prominent in the story?

Is it boring?

Is there originality?

Do you grab the reader’s attention?

Narration -/20

How does the narrator get involved with the story?

Is the narration bias and unclear?

Do you stick with the same narration?

How much do we see based on the narration being told?

Is the story delivered well, are we being told what being told. Remember show, don’t tell.

Themes/Values -/20

Is there a theme?

Is it obvious or do the readers have to read between the lines?

Are values of the character impacting how they react to situations?

Grammar / Spelling - /30

Tense

Punctuation

Metalanguage

Specific words so they aren’t vague.

Mistakes

Correct dialogue

Sensory language

Writing style-/10

Is it clear?

Can readers understand the plot?

Is the sentences structuring correct?

Is it unique?

What sets you apart from other authors?

How the story is written?

Visual -/15

Is the story set out nicely?

Do you have a poster and if it’s nice?

Do you have a layout?

Personal enjoyment -/5

Did I like it?

How did I feel while reading it?

Mark out of 170

 

 

 

 

Like this story? Give it an Upvote!
Thank you!

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
KJB0LD
#1
Chapter 2: Does a story have to be complete yet to have it reviewed??
booobbypooh
#2
Author/s username: booobbypooh
Author/s link to profile: http://www.asianfanfics.com/profile/view/969421
Title of the story: Spoiler
Link to the story. http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/932576/spoiler-angst-friendship-hanbin-teamb-bobby-doubleb-ikon
Complete:. Yes
Current chapter chount:. 23
Password: Soulless souls
Genre/s: friendship
Short Summary: Story about Bobby who is suffering from his bestfriends that always talk behind his back.
Comments: how can I improve this story?
honestly
#3
Author/s username: honestly
Author/s link to profile: http://www.asianfanfics.com/profile/view/293995
Title of the story: chromatics
http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/1023344/
Complete:. Yes
Current chapter count:. 1
Password: soulless souls
Genre/s: crime/thriller? idk
Short Summary : a fic where jongin is an uninspired artist who meets 3 people who bring color into his life
Comments: Anything you want to tell me or want me to focus on?
this is a sort of like a pilot so I dont think the characterization and plot is developed enough lol. I plan on expanding and adding more later but I would like to know what you think of the writing style . :)
aldrusy
#4
Author/s username: Princepao
Author/s link to profile: http://www.asianfanfics.com/profile/view/877850
Title of the story: Hotel Room Escapade
Link to the story: http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/975721/1/
Complete:. Yes
Current chapter count: 1
Password: soulless souls
Genre/s: Romance, -- I hope you're okay with that.
Short Summary: While everyone might be fooled when Suho said that Zitao rooms with him whenever they have to stay at a hotel, Chanyeol knows better.
They both know it's wrong, but neither does something about it.
Comments: This is actually an old story and I think I did decently with this one (???) Just, idk. I want to know what you think about it? : )
Ryeona
#5
Author/s username: Ryeona
Author/s link to profile: http://www.asianfanfics.com/profile/view/302526
Title of the story: 인어의 눈물 (Baby, Don’t Cry)
Link to the story: http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/1017558/1/baby-don-t-cry-exo-sehun-joy-redvelvet
Complete: Yes
Current chapter chount: 1/oneshot
Password: soulless souls
Genre/s: romance
Short Summary: Se-hun believes in reincarnation. Through his dreams he discovered he has done a terrible sin. Now it his chance to redeem himself and save his first love.
Comments: Congratulations on the new opening! I hope it prosper as it gains more and more attention.
OlleriGolleri
#6
Chapter 1: Author/s username: ollerigolleri
Author/s link to profile: http://www.asianfanfics.com/profile/view/952936
Title of the story: That's the Way I Love You
Link to the story: http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/1019437/that-s-the-way-i-love-you-fluff-mino-winner-irene-redvelvet-minguk-minrene
Complete:. Yes
Current chapter count: oneshot
Password: souless souls
Genre/s: fluff, family, sliceoflife
Short Summary: A misunderstanding occurred between Irene and Mino, where their son acted as their Cupid for the day.
Comments: Just take your time, and congratulations for the new opening. The concept of hugs and kisses to be loved and painful at the same time was good. I liked it.
Thanks in advance ice tea!