When you attend Super Show 5, you get lost and run into Eunhyuk. He tries to help you and ends up inviting you backstage where you meet the other members, including Donghae. After the show ends, Donghae and Eunhyuk offer to take you home and spill that they both like you. You can't pick between them so they offer a sort of test to help you pick.

You come home from class late and are surprised to find Hyukjae in your apartment cooking you dinner.