Comments: Der Märchenclub

← Back to story

All Comments (3265)

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
jarinoona
#1
Chapter 4: Oh my goodness, I'm shivering in excitement and suspense! *clicking next*
erahmaliati21 #2
Chapter 55: Omg i'm so speechless here author-nim..
to be honest i'm not a fan of supergeneration but boom! You describe the characters so well and.. unexpected..
thanks for writing a great story author-nim, i'm sad because i didn't find your story earlier..
clandestinelips
#3
Chapter 55: You've done such a phenomenal job with this tale, it is both so heartbreaking and captivating at the same time. The thought and devotion you have to this story really shines through every single chapter, and your aesthetic execution is a cherry on top! I just admire your creativity and it inspires me to think outside of my own box :)

What my favorite aspect is about this entire story is that you have effectively created a very ambiguous grey area of what we define as good and evil. I just love how the characters had their own reasons to catalyzing events in the story. They were given such versatile personalities and motivations, and each one of them with good development. Seriously, I am in awe of every single character you've created.

And the fact that you've given the story a fairytale theme is just too perfect for me. I initially thought it would be a difficult ploy to pull off, and I'm sure it was, but it came off so effortlessly.

I feel very lucky to have this all completed because I am sure if I was waiting like your other readers, I would have been so impatient, haha!

Beautiful work, I really look up to you a lot :)
clandestinelips
#4
Chapter 21: Kyuhyun's arc is by far the saddest, and yet, my favorite in this story. It is so cryptic, but enchanting at the same time how his storyline falls in line with Peter Pan. It's tragic, yet beautiful.
clandestinelips
#5
Chapter 13: It's so riveting and complex! I really admire the grim and calculating storyline, especially now with Taeyeon as something of a wildcard, in my opinion. I'm looking forward to understanding the motives of this "game". All the characters are so diverse and you aren't afraid to paint them in twisted ways. From the beginning, I've really enjoyed the fairytale incorporation into this story, again especially everyone's invitation. It's both mesmerizing and eerie at the same time.
Valenishax #6
such an amazing story, the way you describes all of the members. This is my first time reading fanfic about suju or snsd. But i really love this!! Good job, author nim! :)
auliace #7
Chapter 55: good job~ i don't even ship super generation, but this is daebaaaaaak
iheartchanyeol_
#8
i read this before, about 5-6 chaps but stopped reading bc i found that the story was too long. but im gonna start reading again because i've come to like long stories hehehe
cintaMaharani #9
authornim..., you did a great job..
* sorry i can't write to much, cause i'm worst in english....
babyvin #10
Chapter 22: Good job authornim, I love the way you write the conv and every detail the casts do !
ByungHannie
#11
Despite the story, I have to admit that your trailers are the best as far as I've seen
HailieKibum
#12
Chapter 55: I have never read such a well thought and manipulated story. This is the best fanfic I have read so far - if not the best tale of all. You did a wonderful job, really. I can't even express how profoundly impressed I am with this story and how much I loved it.
dumbutt #13
this is still really the best story i have read on aff and i dont even ship super generation
chiing
#14
still not getting old for me. even if I had read this last year it still feels new to me. still my favorite fic!! ♥
natsumi4ever
#15
Chapter 55: ........Nooooo!!!!this ending!!!!T^<
Hey!!this was an awesome fic but it was so sad at the same time and this ending just really makes me want to scream and cry at knowing it's never over!!!!
But on the upside I really liked heechuls and Jessica's moments and bickering and I found kibum's character to be interesting!!:)
And I've only guessed a few of the characters right!!
Well this is all I'll say!! Bye!!!
HailieKibum
#16
Chapter 38: No, not for him. For them.
HailieKibum
#17
Chapter 38: I-- I simply loved this side-story. It was perfect and it made me shed a tear or two. Kibum is truly something else. Zhou Mi, Henry and Bao are his true family to him and I can't even begin to explain how much I felt for him.
HailieKibum
#18
Chapter 37: This is the chapter in which I cried the most. In fact - it's the only chapter in which I cried. Wookie's death... It was the thing that affected me the most so far in this story.