Review Rubric and Request Form

There will be 3 types of rubrics in our reviews. They will be determined by the number of chapters you have in your fics. Uncompleted stories will be reviewed based on the number of current chapters. Read thoroughly and fill in your requests accordingly on this blog comment.


Review Rubric - A (100 marks) For stories with more than 15 chapters.

Title : (/5)

Appearances : (/5)

Appearances include posters, layouts, trailers and fonts used.

Description/Foreword: (/10)

Plot/Originality: (/20)

Characterization: (/20)

Mechanics: (/20)

Grammar, spelling and punctuation...

Flow/Pace: (/10)

Writing Style: (/5)

Overall Enjoyment: (/5)


Review Rubric - B (100 marks) For stories with less than 15 chapters.

Title: (/10)

Plot: (/10)

Story Structure: (/20)

Your description/foreword, flow and logic go here.

Writing Style: (/10)

Mechanics: (/20)

Characterization: (/20)

Extra/Bonuses: (/10)

Additional poster, layouts and overall enjoyment.


Review Rubric - C (100 marks) For one-shot to three-shots

Title: (/15)

First Impressions: (/15)

Storyline: (/10)

Characterization: (/10)

Story Structure: (/20)

Mechanics: (/20)

Extra/Bonus: (/10)


Request Form:

Author: Link to your profile

Story: Link to the story

Genre:

Rubric type: (A, B or C)

Preffered Reviewer:

Additional information or concerns:

Password:

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
WafiRosli
#1
Author: http://www.asianfanfics.com/profile/view/818931
Story: http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/859769/in-one-night-malay-oneshot-horror-malay-mystery-luhan-phsychological-malayhorrorcreepy-horrorcreepy
Genre: Horror
Rubric type: C
Preffered Reviewer: anyone
Additional information or concern: Saya buat cerita ini tanpa plot sepertimana yang selalu saya lakukan. Cerita ini saya hasilkan segar dari otak sehinggakan watak protagonis lelaki itupun hanya diletak tanpa berfikir panjang. Cerita oneshot ini juga merupakan cerita terpendek yang pernah saya hasilkan kerana tidak menulis sebarang plot.
Password: Take Care Of Yourself For Me
little-deer
#2
Author: http://www.asianfanfics.com/profile/view/131437
Story: http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/787650/
Genre: mystery, romance
Rubric type: B
Preffered Reviewer: anyone
Additional information or concerns: Saya rasa saya ada buat banyak kesilapan, jadi saya perlukan seseorang untuk menegur. :> Dan saya bimbang yang saya tak dapat nak habiskan fanfic ni sebab ketandusan idea yang boleh membuatkan saya give up untuk sambung. :v
Password: Take Care Of Yourself For Me
Decode01
#3
Author: http://www.asianfanfics.com/profile/view/853574

Story: http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/863800/kill-or-being-killed-angst-friendship-horror-malay-exo-kyungsoo

Genre: friendship,apocalypse,angst,horror

Rubric type: c

Preffered Reviewer: anyone

Additional information or concerns: take your time to review ^^

Password: take care of yourself for me!
daisy25
#4
Author : daisy25
http://www.asianfanfics.com/profile/view/793076
Story : The Pain
http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/822942/the-pain-malay-baekhyun
Genre : sad/angst
Rubric type : c
Preffered reviewer : anyone
Additional information or concerns : --
Password : take care of yourself for me
AiSyah98
#5
Author:AiSyah98
Story:https://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/861569/disebalik-mekap-si-badut-comedy-malay-romantic-exo-sehun
Genre:romantic/comedy/drama
Rubric type:A
Preffered Reviewer:anyone
Additional information or concern:-
password:take care of yourself for me
juniorarmy
#6
Author: Juniorarmy http://www.asianfanfics.com/profile/view/600141

Story: My Ex And The Annoying Boy http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/855620/my-ex-and-the-annoying-boy-comedy-romance-you-bts-taehyung-hanbin-ikon

Genre: comedy , romance 

Rubric type:  B

Preffered Reviewer: anyone

Additional information or concerns: -

Password:take care of yourself for me
HeavenDelight
#7
Author: http://www.asianfanfics.com/profile/view/379028

Story : http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/792560/between-life-and-death-angst-fantasy-malay-exo-exok-baekhyun-kyungsoo

Genre: angst,fantasy and romance

Rubric type: C

Preffered Reviewer: tak kisah sesiapa pun,,^^

Additional information or concerns: nothing

Password: take care of yourself for me
HeavenDelight
#8
Author: http://www.asianfanfics.com/profile/view/379028

Story: http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/834043/when-destiny-did-not-belong-to-us-angst-malay-mystery-bromance-exo-chanyeol-kyungsoo

Genre: Angst,sad and mystery

Rubric type: B

Preffered Reviewer: tak kisah sesiapa pun,,^^

Additional information or concerns: buat masa sekarang,story ni belum lebih 15 chapter,so saya pilih rubric B tapi kesuluruhan chapter mungkin akan lebih dari 15..^^

Password: take care of yourself for me
amiramuliyadi
#9
Author : amiramuliyadi (http://www.asianfanfics.com/profile/view/763324)
Story : demi (http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/807789/demi-contest-kimjongin-dokyungsoo-yoonasnsd)
Genre : friendship , angst
Runic type : c
Preffered viewer : anyone
Additional information or concern : nothing
Password : Take Care of Yourself for Me
Jelly_Warrior
#10
Author: Loizhong_96 ( http://www.asianfanfics.com/profile/view/599512 )
Story: Last Origami ( http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/788181/last-origami-beast-family-malay-doojoon-bap-banglo-theadventurine
Genre:Angst,Family
Rubric type: (A, B or C):C
Preffered Reviewer:Anyone^^
Additional information or concerns:Nothing maybe~~^^
Password:Take Care Of Yourself For Me
ShiningStar99 #11
Author: shiningStar99 : http://www.asianfanfics.com/profile/view/670091
Story : I'm Sorry : http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/815341/i-m-sorry-friendship-malay-suzy-yoona-yuri-writtingcontest-theadventurine
Genre: Friendship, angst
Rubic type: c *4 shot, can I?*
Preffered reviewer: anyone :)
Additional information or concerns: -
Password: Take Care of Yourself for me
Hundotlove
#12
Request Form:
Author: syafiqahhottest http://www.asianfanfics.com/profile/view/295450
Story: Pretty Girl http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/784396/pretty-girl-family-fantasy-friendship-krystal-malay-suzy-theadventurine
Genre: Fantasy,Friendship,Revenge,Family
Rubric type: C *one-shot tapi 4 chap uhh stil C or not*
Preffered Reviewer: Anyone
Additional information or concerns: I hope you would help me with ending T^T
Password: Take Care of Yourself for me