What netizens said: 

Boram not acknowledging Hwayoung as maknae in T-ara because on Hyomin’s birthday, Hyomin called Hyomin as a second maknae. Since Hwayoung is older than Jiyeon by a few months and Hyomin is 89er, Hwayoung suppose to be a second maknae not Hyomin. On Jiyeon birthday, Boram also wished Jiyeon by called her forever maknae Jiyeon. 

Translation: you are not pretty, not y, not even cute (I was joking haha) Happy Birthday to our T-ara second maknae Hyomin♥♪ ♫ ♬ ♩

Translation: Happy Birthday to our forever maknae Jiyeon♥♡♥♡. Although unnie is now wishing you in hospital but the next time we meet I will be recovered already♥ Prepare to get trouble againㅡ!!۶(✷ㅅ✷)۶

The truth is: 

On Hwayoung birthday, Boram wished Hwayoung and called her maknae! 

Translation: Always looking down on unni, our tallㅡmaknae Hwayoungie. Happy birthday★☆ pats ♥

So, what is the problem here? Boram called Hyomin as the second maknae???

Here we go…

Jiyeon and Hwayoung both born in 1993 so they actually a same age friends. In this case, both of them actually a maknae in T-ara. But in T-ara fandom, since Jiyeon is the youngest by a few month than Hwayoung, so she become the official maknae. Just like one group only need one leader, we can only have one official maknae in a group. Position as maknae in the group quite important in idol world because maknae will represent the cuteness of the group so in public and media eyes, Jiyeon is the official maknae!

Is that changed the fact that Hwayoung also the T-ara’s maknae in T-ara members’ eyes? The answer is NO!

Boram called Hyomin as the second maknae because for her, since Jiyeon and Hwayoung in the same age, they are the 1st maknaes in T-ara. Boram’s tweet on Hwayoung birthday is the proof! Of course netizens don’t bother to cap the tweet and post it (¬-̮¬)

Netizens then point out the words ‘Forever maknae Jiyeon’ in Boram’s tweet!

What’s wrong with that words??? Jiyeon indeed a maknae in T-ara so nothing wrong with that words! CCM announced the addtion of two new members a few weeks before Jiyeon birthday so with the addition of Areum and Dani who is younger than Jiyeon, Jiyeon is not longer a maknae in T-ara. The words “Forever maknae’ probably means that, for Boram, even though Jiyeon is no longer a maknae in the group, she will always look at Jiyeon as the youngest one.

This is the translation from BNT Interview when the reporter asked Boram about her opinion rearding the addition of new members.

“I look forward to it. I’m happy yet worried at the same time. At times I think ‘will they be able to adjust?,’ but when I see the members’ cheerful selves, all of my worries disappear. I don’t think they’ll have any trouble adjusting. More than that, when I see our little ones ‘Jiyeon’ and ‘Hwayoung’ doting on the new members, I smile unknowingly. Should I call it an ‘auntie’s heart’?”

http://bntnews.hankyung.com/apps/news?popup=0&nkey=201206191027473&c1=04&c2=03&nid=04&mode=sub_view

EXTRA!!!

Eunjung to Hwayoung: 

우리 막내애기 화영이의 생일입니다!!! 많이많이축하해주세요>∇

Translation: It’s our maknae baby Hwayoungie’s birthday!!! Please send her a lot of your greetings !!!! Having you next to me..I’m so used to it by now..and I can’t have you away from me!! ㅋㅋ You’re completely capable of doing well, I believe in your ability♥I love you!!!!

Hwayoung replied: 

@taraeunjung1212 고마워언니!!!!! ㅋㅋ뒹굴뒹굴겸댕이 내 백구언니ㅎㅎ

@taraeunjung1212 Thank you unni!!!!! ㅋㅋ Cutie cutie, my Baekgu unniㅎㅎ

Hyomin to Hwayoung:

Translation: It’s our big baby Hwayoungie’s birthday ♥ Everyone please congratulate her~~ ^^ Happy birthday Ryu Hwayoung!!!!

Hwayoung replied:

@b89530 ㅋㅋ아 또언니랑 연습하고싶땅ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ콜해 ㅋㅋ

@b89530 ㅋㅋ Ah I want to practice with unni againㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ Call me ㅋㅋ

Jiyeon to Hwayoung:

룡룡이생일축하해!!!! 음하하 선물은내일줄게..♥ 우리룡룡이축하해주세요!!!

Ryongryongie happy birthday!!!! Eumhaha I’ll give you your present tomorrow..♥ Please congratulate our Ryongryongie!!!

@pjy1234 크르릉~~~박찌롱ㅋㅋㅋ고맙따잉!! 우리내일피자맛있게만들자ㅋㅋ

@pjy1234 Keureureung~~~Park JjirongㅋㅋㅋThanks!! Let’s make a yummy pizza tomorrowㅋㅋ

source: http://hyotheleader.tumblr.com/post/28624171772/rumor-vs-fact-t-aras-bullying-case-evidence-11

------------------

it really seems like T-ara and Hwayoung is having a really good relationship so i wonder why they are suddenly accused of bullying!

anyway, i know they can survive this... Queens, this is the time where the girls needed our support the most~

lets not leave their side and stay strong... HWAITING!!