Girls’ Generation‘s maknae Seohyun is once again receiving attention for her consistent, unchanging beauty.

An online community board recently posted the photo collage above, writing, ‘Seohyun, From Her Audition Until Now‘, with several past snapshots of Seohyun including her S.M. Entertainment audition photo, and more recent pictures after her debut.

In all of the pictures, there is basically no difference in Seohyun’s appearance. The innocent image she has now as a young woman followed her from her youth. The picture taken when Girls’ Generation first debuted especially accentuates her simple, innocent beauty.

Netizens responded to the pictures saying, “Seohyun’s pictures make me think she was always beautiful“, “She hasn’t changed at all. Seohyun is the winner of past photos“, and “She’s looked innocent since she was little”.