the big comeback?! Hate all you want, shawols.

Attention rant ahead!


I´m thoroughly disappointed with this comeback. So from the start:

 

The first teaser of Minho was quite a shock, the second ... oh boy... undressed Taemin, I know he´s grown up now but he´s still the youngest. Well to me it was clear that it was going to be some sort of french-boho  bordello  type of concept. And even though I already hated those locks on Minho I cant deny that I missed Taemin´s Lucifer hair. xD he looks gorgeous with that!!!!


but then... oh boy... it went downhill. I mean seriously, Onew? A blanket? What´s there to hide anyway? it´s not like Minho and Taem were packed with abs. No one expected that but ... sigh... it seems he really got stuck in the mental-youngest spot. =_=
(p.s.: he´s my bias so it does pain me to write that and maybe I only feel so strongly about this because I was ready for an ovary explosion)
Key did a good job though. I think out of all the boys his pictures look best. But I still don´t know what to make of whatever landed under his lips. It´s probably supposed to be a piercing but the skin doesn´t really look like that. But it´s Key, so who knows?

Now Jonghyun... xD
tbh ... I didn´t recognize him right away. He looks like he got a lot leaner and his features look softer. but yeah.

I thoroughly disliked the group shots... the whole hair disaster sans Taemin, is fully shown. Grown out highlights and frizzy looking hair.
We have landed in hobo-hippie land and I am not a happy camper.

I would have tossed all the bad thoughts away if Rino did their choreography (adore her and her work) but no.... it´s Tony Testa... and so far I´m not a huge fan of his choreos.
Why couldn´t SME get someone cooler? with more style?? ... how about IamMe?? Ellen Kim? Nika kljun? There are lots of more talented dancers out there. I know Tony has the reputation.. he worked with kylie minogue and though she is famous she´s not as skilled as Shinee in the dance department (I mean, remember the Lucifer-choreo?!). I´m scared it´ll be memorable moves but lame in comparison to what they did before.

So... it all comes down to one song.

Which is said to be very creative combining 2 songs... which could be a disaster as well. I can´t help but think of SNSD´s "the boys" which sounded like there were 2 or 3 songs mashed into one. Big fail imo. I am really worried this wont work out.

 

I still consider myself a fan (heck look at my fanfics)...but I have waited for so long and a weird concept wasn´t what I wanted. I would have clearly waited a couple more months if I were then presented with polished stylish looks and an awesome song.

 

Photobucket

 

Maybe some of you felt the same? and were a little disappointed too? Or at least confused xD


 

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
Supriya
#1
Tell me about it! About the choreographer. Idk much about Testa but I can see that SHINee's other choreos overshine their Sherlock's. It's nothing great and since it is nothing great, it is not SHINee's style. They have the best choreos I know. They should have just had Rino choreo them. Tsk tsk. I hope SM abandons the idea of colloborating with Testa anymore. Rino is my girl! She's just super cool.
legendariiphresh
#2
I saw Taemin and I freaked out, because it disturbed me so much. And Minho's didn't faze me, but I atleast expected Jjong to be topless too. He was still gorgeous, but I could've taken a better shot than that on my nikon. No, I could've done better with my phone. I just ... I don't... Somebody get rid of the Taemin pic atleast, cuz it makes me feel like SM is gonna get sued for ual abuse of a minor. Come on SM, put some effort in. I like Shinee too much for this.
aerokinesis #3
I'm not a Shawol at all so I'm probably already biased as . Yet I can't help but laugh everytime I see those pictures.. To me, SMent seriously has the worse stylists when it comes to fashion. I didn't like any of their concepts apart from Replay and Ring Ding Dong, same goes to a lot other SM groups.

But even though I never liked their styling, this is probably the worse they had. It's weird. And I feel like they came out from , indeed. Some Shawols were ranting on AFF about how people were hating on their looks, but seriously, you can't say the styling has went well! I hope that their next concept and styling will be better :\ I really do.