Silence

So I made a blog about this but then I deleted it shortly after because I thought it was crappy so I’m gonna try again lmao.

 

You may be aware of this issue on AFF, it’s silent yet deafening: silent readers. It’s not my first time seeing this issue being brought up on this website and after spending a good amount of years here, it’s honestly disappointing to see it continue to be a prevailing issue.

 

Here on AFF, we all come here to show our love for our favorites in a number of creative ways; designing, role-playing, and most commonly - writing. There are over a million stories here done by thousands of authors available in so many genres that could be thought of on this website for you to read from. Among all those stories, we have a plethora of creative plots and they still keep on coming to this day. To remind you, authors here are doing this for free. Creativity for your own enjoyment is not free outside of this website and just in the world of fandoms overall. I think people are forgetting that and that is often taken for granted.

 

The only form of payment that these authors would generally receive from their stories are karma points. And that is often earned through from readers subscribing, upvoting, or commenting

 

I don’t heavily stress on having readers comment on my stories but I won’t deny that it feels damn good to receive one. Seeing that white globe turn orange with a “New story comments” notification gets my heart pumping. I’m curious and thrilled to see what my readers think of what I’ve written. I can’t help it. And no matter how short or long it is, I love it. I often reply to all of them back but sometimes I’m not articulate enough to come up with a good response so I would wind up upvoting that comment but I’m hoping to fix that very soon. 

 

And with the recent attention of the issue, I can’t help but be reminded of my previous experiences on my old accounts here on this website. Previously as an author, I spend my waking and sometimes even sleeping hours coming up with good story ideas and bringing them to life through writing up to the point where my brain feels like it’s being fried relentlessly. It’s tiring and nearly draining. And when I publish the chapter, I hope that effort I put in is worth it. And when I notice that I receive very little to no comments, I often ponder my worth and skill as an author even though it was just a hobby. That has led me to lose motivation quickly and I would often delete my stories without notice. I can’t tell you how many times I had left this website and came back with new accounts, only to delete them again when the problem continued. It was incredibly disheartening.

 

I don’t want to generalize, blame, or guilt silent readers into commenting, I completely understand the reasons why they wouldn’t: not comfortable to speak, don’t want to embarrass themselves, be annoying/redundant to the author. But I assure you, any kind of comment no matter how bad you think it is will make your author’s day. I’ve been a silent reader before and it took a long time for me to begin commenting on the stories I would read and it felt good. And seeing the author reply back is enlightening, it’s like we hear and recognize each other. And for once, I didn’t feel so unheard and alone.

 

I don’t want to force anyone to get out of their comfort zone immediately, so please take your time. Do what you need to do to get to that point. But I will highlight the fact that readers are the literal backbone of this website. Having your voice be heard allows for authors to continue sharing their creativity and ideas for you to enjoy, you guys keep this website alive. If you’re one of the silent readers out there, please let yourselves be known. Like the authors here, your words are just as powerful as theirs.

 

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
_Misu_
#1
I can't agree more...comments will let us progress & have better stories...
Not only here but sharing ideas & letting people know their weak points...so they try to improve it...also they'll understand what is good to keep...so we'll have a better society & then a better world...
Lost_Pharaoh
#2
I can agree with this but we all got to remember that we are not writing to get the appreciation of other. We write because of the messages we want to send, conversations we want to hear and worlds we want want to explore. It's nice to get readers and better if they comment but we cannot let this makes us feels down.

Writing is what we love to do for fun.

But don't worry about it; no comments doesn't mean it's bad. There are great fanfics with no comments and awful fanfics with hundreds. It's not a good measurement of quality.
Agent_K
#3
All I want to say is, thank you. From the bottom of my heart.
I have been struggling to voice out my thoughts regarding this matter for a long time but kept failing to do so. I did mention about this in my story, but, still people read but they seriously don't respond. It feels as if they are not interested at all.
There was a time when I really wanted to say, why even bother to subscribe when you don't even want to share what you think about something you are reading that I have worked hard on? But then I understood that maybe they are shy or they don't want to really share their thoughts... but it gets frustrating you know. It demotivates you to the point that I no longer wish to update.

Once again, thank you.
JaeKnight
#4
As a non-reader, Im totally clueless what a fanfic reader might feel, so i had no idea what it meant when getting a reply. But when i did try reading, what i felt is that —“wow idk what to say but i want to say something” so i thought collecting thoughts can be a challenge for some. And when i get a reply, im like, “aaa pls dont reply to me i just want you to let you know my thoughts. I know youre gonna read it” 😂 i guess we’re all different.



But thank you for this! I totally agree that a reader’s words are just as powerful as the author’s as they are the real— somewhat like—” judge” of the story.

Idk if youve read this somewhere but 👀 “I just paint. and you interpret it. And how you perceive it is what makes the art meaningful.” 👀
NeverNinaa
#5
I know it's totally not related to the subject of the blog post, but your profile picture😭 I'm stealing it!!!
Shrysea
#6
It took me sometimes to comment as well, mostly because I was selecting completed stories and thought it was too late to comment each chapter so I would only comment once for a complete story instead.
Then I started reading ongoing stories ( being still afraid to be deceived by a hiatus or a drop of the said story) and when I saw authors asking at the end of the chapter about what we thought about some mystery plot or twisted plot I had the will to comment and answer because the author made a kind of connection with the reader asking it a direct question on a particular subject related to his ou her story and not vaguely asking for comment.
now that I am myself an author I understand more the thrill to receive chapter comment but yet it is not so for being comforted about my author's status and the quality of my work but more to the pleasure to interact with other, readers, authors and Kpop fan ^^
Scarlet_Sky
#7
Exactly my thoughts! You summed it up perfectly. Comments are such a big motivation, but I think some readers either dont realize or dont care.
I see many readers who subscribe and never interact with me. It makes me sad, honestly. I dont bite and I dont care about grammar mistakes or whatever either, I'm not a native speaker myself. Whether it's a few words or a whole paragraph, every comment makes me happy. And I bet it's the same for other authors too!
I think if you're taking something, then you could also give something back! :3
Sway10
#8
I have never been a silent reader, even when I started reading fanfictions. For me it was always nice to voice my own thoughts about the story or how I think it might continue. It's fun. I also hope to make the author a little happy when commenting, kinda in a way to say thank you for writing this story.
I barely get comments myself but it doesn't bother me as much. I don't write well and it's just a hobby. But when someone comments I am just as excited as you :)
Minhospuppy
#9
SAY IT LOUDER!! Like I mean even a small "I love it." Or "good work" Makes my day and even tho ppl say comments and upvotes does not define the quality of your work, writers feel content only if they get to know that the readers like it. If there's no comments or likes, it's like giving a speech with blind folds on and having no response back. If you get what I mean. It's really sad I hope it changes soon tbh
pyonsuke
#10
Well said hunie :(