Why Authors Really Need Comments!

I read this on tumblr, so credit to all the users there that contributed to this thread. I thought that this explained really well why most authors here want comments when they post new chapters. It's not about praise, or fans, it's about communication and apreciation of the work they just spent hours making, wheather it be a good or bad response.

schrodingersowenDeactivated

no but really, like 

i know that some folks love telling creative people that “you should be doing it for fun because you love it not for the compliments” but creative people thrive on feedback whether it’s critical or just complimentary

so when i write fanfiction and don’t get any actual feedback i feel like i spent all that time and energy doing it for nothing because i’m not getting feedback from the people i wrote it for 

doing something you’re proud of and then presenting it to the sound of utter silence is like the worst feeling on earth 

I know the feeling of this.

i like to think: what if you were in a play and you spend all that time learning your lines and your cues and going to rehearsal for hours and hours and being bone tired and then getting up on stage opening night and giving it your all only to be met with silence from the audience at the final curtain call. No one would question why that upset them.
 

An art instructor in my childhood said something to me I’ve never forgotten - that a work of art isn’t complete until it has been experienced - seen, heard, etc.  That this wasn’t just some abstract concept, but a visceral truth for the artist - that the work wasn’t DONE until the end result had been witnessed, appreciated, critiqued - whatever, it didn’t have to be positive negative knowledgable, it just had to happen as the concluding event, the final brush .

Some folks who don’t get it go about thinking we make art or write fic because we crave praise or attention or fans, or even that some writers/artists thrive on negativity and drama (and to be sure, all of these things are true some times!).  But that’s too narrow an understanding of why we art. I think my art teacher was telling a fundamental truth about the psychology of creativity - that art is a communal experience, that until we share our creative work and see how people respond, we do not have closure on that work.  

Art is communication - and communication shouted into the void is frighteningly isolating. We need our readers our viewers our audience. We need to hear what you think. We need to converse in comments, answer your counter thoughts or thoughtful critique, we need the conversation - that’s what art is :)

Never feel bad for desiring feedback - it’s not some extra frill that exists outside of the creative process. It is a critical part of the creative process - and if you cannot find your audience in one venue, don’t give up.  Keep putting your art out there until your audience finds you :)

Yes: that.

I don’t make art because I enjoy it. I make art because I am trying to communicate. And if it fails to elicit any response at all, or I can’t even tell if anyone saw it/read it then I have failed, or will suspect I have failed, to communicate and I’m gonna feel bad about that.

Same goes for writing folks.

-Morgan

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
mailoony
#1
Comments also motivates writers and we're reading their work for free. It's the least we can do for them.
But they don't comment anyway. :'(
Ellyjelly96
#2
Man I wish I could press I like button on this or there was some sort of top blogs haha
I agree with all of this. I haven't really been up for posting chapters or stories on here because I don't get feedback. I get biased feedback from people who anticipate but no criticism, no strong views on my they like or hate the characters or what they read. It's discouraging really and that's why I might have to stop writing about super junior and start writing about exo, bts and got7 to get enough readers and then get critics.

I don't want to stop posting on aff because my work is protected here through not being able to highlight and copy. So comments are needed!!
turyka #3
So i must say sorry for not leaving comments lately.. I'm actually on gtop mode right now ^^ . but just to let you know i always appreciate your hard work, your stories are really well written and developt...
In general I really respect writers (everytime I want to quit I find a plot that huck me up ), specially the ones that through his stories make you feel the emotions of the characters, the ones that can transport you from the "real" world and the ones that think more that just a perfect ending for their bias couple.
And I agree some ppl need a feedback specially the beginners to encourage them to keep writing.. or just a thxs 4 the update or thxs 4 writing or good job or keep doing ...IDK, so many short comments.
But I must say not all the writters accept all kinds of feedbacks, It happened to me once so I rather don't leave a criticism when i'm not satisfied with the chapter unless I feel extremely confortable with the author or if him/her had since the beginning stablished that they don't mind.
I just hope some readers "read" this post and comment more ^^
bigbangluv143
#4
This is so right! I can't believe how much I agree to what these people are saying! And not to lie but it's a big relief to see that other people crave the response of comments. With this post I feel that I can be more motivated to keep writing stories and hoping at least someone's day will be better with my stories.
Hayaley #5
Love this! And I totally agree with Banana654321.
I know I'm going to continue to write whether or not I get comments but I feel more motivated when I see comments. It tells me I'm heading in the right direction (or not), which helps me to improve. I don't know if we can ever get readers to understand this. I think unless they are writers themselves, it's hard to get through to them.
AmySuju
#6
I can't agree more, once i felt this and i voice it out and the reader tell me what you just wrote. Do it for fun, when when spent an hours to finish it, a simple comment won't hurt at all but reader is just a lil bit selfish sometime.
Banana654321
#7
This should go viral on aff and all sites. It's the simplest way of making people understand that feedback isn't compliment fishing (all the time), it's actually finding comfort and improvement through other people's perspective. An author may be good at writing but this does not mean that they're perfect. comments and critique alike will be their foundation into becoming a better writer.

I totally feel for this, permission to repost please. :)
bbibaekie
#8
I 100% agree with this! When I don't get comments I just feel like nobody liked what I spent hours creating...I am dyslexic and I want to have feedback to feel like I did well and that my dyslexia didn't ruin the chapters etc.
MyMinnie
#9
I can understand what they are saying and I'm certain that 99% of writers need that kind of feedback to keep the creative juices flowing, but for me comments seem to place an unnecessary burden on me, whether good or bad. So I don't mind if there are no comments on any of my stories. I've had publishers wanting to turn the nonsense in my head into actual books, but I've always said no because for me, writing is supposed to be fun and I think comments and expectations can turn what I do for fun into a burden. Does that make me weird? (You don't have to comment)
Neko-Meow
#10
Ifkr? I agree to agree on this post like literally. Sometimes I feel un-appreciated when I don't get comments. I feel like my writings weren't good enough or my hardwork didn't pay off anyway. Can I share this? I'll credit you,of course.
Wonachan
#11
yep, but people don't comment anyway,
heclgehog
#12
It kind posting on here too bc it only seems like people only care about pairings and they only want to leave comments regarding when/if the two lead characters will ever get together.
It's damn near impossible to write about a platonic realtionship on here w/o having several readers comment only regarding "when will so and so get together???? I ship them" like do you even read the story for the plot? Do you even give a about anything besides "romance"?
Nathaliafl123
#13
Same. Comments give me life and I always look forward to them when I log into AFF. Thanks, LadyVamp, for mentioning this :-)
danica84
#14
I agree 150%! I love hearing what people think about what I've written even if it's not good, give me something. I do have a few readers who I know I'll hear something from but I'd love me. I know my stories aren't epic novels but something would be nice. I've even gotten to the point where I don't even ask for comments anymore at the ends of my chapters because I know I'll barely get any.