Hello, and welcome to CavityFree Reviews.  Worried about your story's hygiene?  Need a little filling? Well, you've come to the right place. :D

Please read EVERYTHING below before requesting our cleaning services.

Rules

- Subscription is not mandatory, but you must leave a comment confirming you've read your review WITHIN a week after your review is published.  If you have time, please let us know what was/wasn't helpful. Since we are brand new to reviewing, this is especially helpful for us. 

- Reviews are karma-free, but it would be nice of you to upvote if you found the review helpful; consider that your "payment." :D

- M/M, M/F, F/F are all fine.  Any genre is fine.  Any idols are fine, though there are some groups we are more familiar with than others. Personally, we think it's better when the reviewer isn't too familiar with the group, because then s/he can give accurate feedback on how well you fleshed out the characters.

- Please do NOT submit:

stories with , adult/minor relationships, and mental illness unless you are sure that you treated the topic seriously.  [Hint: if you are not sure, you probably haven't] 

stories that are longer than 10K or incomplete.

- One of us is busy with upcoming AP/SAT/ACT/other awful acronymed tests, so don't rush us please. However, if we do not return your review 2 weeks after you've been put in the "review in progress" category, feel free to bug us.

- Please do not cancel your request once it is in progress.

- We will be concise but hopefully thorough with our reviews. If you'd like more detailed explanation we are happy to provide them.  We will be respectful with our reviews and back up claims, so please do the same in return.

- Please give credit where it is due.

"Grading" Rubric (out of 100)

We would hope that our comments are much more helpful than the numerical "scores" themselves.  Since there are so many types of stories in the world, scores are not an accurate reflections of how enjoyable a story is.  For example, a story with an OC with a nondistinct personality is naturally going to get little points in characterization, even if it was an intentional choice on the author's part.  Or, we might give a sci-fi epic less points than a character study because the rubric emphasizes characters more than setting/worldbuilding. We suggest you look over the rubric to make sure you are okay with our scoring criteria before requesting a scored review.  If you are here simply to receive a grade, this is probably not the right place for you. If you'd like us to just give you an overall commentary about your story without points, that's fine. Just indicate so in your form. 

In general: 5 = good!, 4 = you mostly have it, 3 = passable, 2 = needs work, 1 = poor.  I don't do fraction points.  I try very hard not to score based on feelings/impressions and I follow a specific checklist for each point I give/take away so that it is as objective as I can make it. Of course, this means that more unusual/experimental stories may get scored "unfairly" but this is the only I way I can think of to make sure everyone is being graded the same way.

Rubric is subject to change, in which case I would re-score your story if it gives you more points. Again, the comments mean more than the scores.

Sounds good?  If you would like our cleaning services, please comment below with this form. (form has been updated)

Title:

Link:

Scored review (longer) or just general comments (shorter):

Anything specific you'd like us to comment on as we perform your cleaning:

Anything else (warnings, disclaimers, explanations, playlists, etc.):

Easy, right? :D We look forward to "brushing up" your story so that you can put your best face forward!