Behind the Porcelain Mask (Reviewed by Gillian)

ミ★ seoul search┊a review shop «status: closed»
Please Subscribe to read the full chapter


Title: "Behind the Porcelain Mask"
Author: JustDerpin
Link: [x]

 

Title ☆ (5/5)
I really like the title. It’s something different and refreshing to see here on Asianfanfics. I’d definitely click if I saw this floating around the site.


Foreword & Description ☆ (6.5/10)
The foreword and the description is pretty good. There were a few spelling mistakes but that’s nothing an editing session can’t fix.

‘Just Because my eyes don’t tear, doresn’t mean my heart doesn’t cry.’ should be: ‘Just because my eyes don’t tear, doesn’t mean my heart doesn’t cry.’

I’m not usually fond of profile character unless it’s really needed but I’m glad you didn’t reveal too much trivial information about the characters.

 

Appearance (Posters/Backgrounds/Banners) ☆  (10/10)
I love the poster and the background, it looks really well-made.


Originality & Creativity ☆  (6.5/10)
Since this story was for a contest and you chose the prompts, I reviewed on the basis of how well you expressed the prompts through your writing and the story overall. I like how all the prompts you chose linked and tied in together with each other with the theme of a mask or hiding behind a mask. Good job to you for seeing the connection between the prompts. Although the connecting prompts was good, it seemed that the way you expressed them through the story was still kind of lacking. Perhaps if you had a stronger plot, it would have been much better.
 


Plot ☆ (15/20)
As for the plot, I felt that it lacked in more depth. You have this story tagged as angst; to be honest, this story isn’t angst at all. I’m not entirely sure which genre this story would come under but I’d say it’s more of drama rather than angst. I was hoping that you expanded more on what ha

Please Subscribe to read the full chapter
Like this story? Give it an Upvote!
Thank you!
ttalgi-
【Seoul-Search】: majority of reviews are going to be done collectively by Jessica and Gillian now, thankyou!

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
JustDerpin
#1
Chapter 14: OMG. thank you so much for being so honest!! >.< I've never noticed those errors until now! ;A; thank you so much! and about the flow.. yeah, I screwed up big time when I was creating the story, and I was rushing it too much :/ *sighs* Well, what's done is done and I've learned from my mistakes so, I hope that the next time I'll get my review here, you won't be so disappointed! ^0^
Yeah, this story I've noticed that this wasn't as angst-y as I wanted it to be and the romance.. ugh. -.- I'm going to change the tag to friendship~ and romance shall be the sequel! >:DD this time with better flow and less rushed XD

anyways, thank you so freaking much!! TT______TT <3
Laydeen
#2
Chapter 12: Thank you very much for the review. I`ll pay more attention especially on the commas and apostrophes >.< And also the sentences and pretty much everything. thank you for your honest review. I appreciate it very much.
Keep up the good work~
shadowkissed
#3
Title: If Tomorrow Does Exist

Story Link: http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/282146/if-tomorrow-does-exist-oneshot-sunggyu-babysoul-soulgyu-babygyu

Author/s: Username; hogyuya

Genre: angst, romance

Rating: G

Pairing: het, GyuSoul (Baby Soul x Sunggyu)

Fandom: Infinite

Ongoing or Complete? completed one shot!

Is English your first language? no...

Specific reviewer? If you want a specific reviewer (either Gillian or Jessica), indicate here. If not, leave this blank.

Thank you! ^^
JustDerpin
#4
Title: Behind the Porcelain Mask

Story Link: http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/279382

Author/s: Just Derpin

Genre: Angst/Slice of Life

Rating: Everyone

Pairing: het

Fandom: EXO

Ongoing or Complete? Complete; three-shot

Is English your first language? No

Specific reviewer? Gillian
Thank you in advance~ ^^
AMizuPen
#5
Chapter 11: Thank you ^ ^ I will take note from your review (:
Laydeen
#6
Title: Uncommitted
Story Link: http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/269560/
Author/s: AutumnHearts
Genre: slice of life, drama, angst
Rating: NC17- there`s no actual , but a scene leading to it (no ual though)
Pairing: Xiumin & EXO (there are moments, though most of it is based simply on friendship)
Fandom: EXO
Ongoing or Complete? Complete, since it`s an one-shot
Is English your first language? No
Specific reviewer? Anyone is fine^^
Thank you in advance~
kyouyas
#7
Title: Aish! That Jung Daehyun!

Story Link: http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/249776/aish-that-jung-daehyun-yongguk-zelo-jongup-bap-daehyun-youngjae-kimnamjoo

Author/s: Username; kpoplistener

Genre: Fluff

Rating: None

Pairing: DaeJoo (DaehyunxNamjoo(OC))

Fandom: B.A.P, EXO and more

Ongoing or Complete? Ongoing and 31 chapters

Is English your first language? Yes

Specific reviewer? 
TheMullekeee
#8
Hey.. TheMullekeee here,
Thank you so so so much for the review, it really is helpfull to me..
I will definitley keep your tips in my mind...
Again thanks a lot.. I'm really happy with your review... ;)
Byeeee~