i chose other because supernatural writings are super hard! if you were to go somewhere in this direction, i would suggest something like a psychological thriller. it's not really supernatural, but it can be eerie and sort of has the same vibe as a supernatural story. i've also found them to be a lot easier to write and a lot more enjoyable to readers, because some people find the whole supernatural thing "cheesy" (not that there's anything wrong with the genre). if you don't really care about the whole "supernatural-writings-are-hard" thing, then i would've chosen the magic and wizards au. good luck!