Comments: Spare the rod, and spoil the child!

← Back to story

All Comments (1969)

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
X-I-U-M-I-N-O-P-P-A
#1
Chapter 22: Oh my lord. Absolutely wonderful, I'm speechless. This is easily one of the greatest things I have ever read, thank you for blessing this fandom with your writing skills. Everything was wonderfully paced and eloquently written and I could not stop reading it. Wonderful job!
zankai_88 #2
Chapter 23: I was just looking for Baekyeol fics to read and I came across this. I saw Harry Potter AU and a long fic and I was game. But damn, was this the best HP AU fic I've ever read! Every Exo member was perfectly sorted and everyone had important roles to play and the plot kept me up for two nights reading everything up like a maniac! I really loved all the suspense, the kinda false leads with Markus and Jung and then the final culprit to be someone I did not expect! This was so well written, the pranks, everyone's interactions with each other and the bickering! 100/10 would read again !
highmixtape
#3
Chapter 23: I dont know why but i have just finished reading it. Firstly, I would like to express my regret of not finding this stpry earlier. Yet this is the joy. A pure joy of a HP and EXO's fan. I admitted that there are a lot of stories with Hogwarts as its AU but this is just a gold. At the start, I didn't find the pace of the story going too fast or slow and this make me enjoy the fiction so much. The mystery, the actions, the thrill and also the adrenalines that I get from just reading this is amazing. Your mind is amazing. Your writing is a masterpiece. I knew it was Yixing's sickly friend all along because his character is too shady and sketchy. Even other side characters would have more interactions with the main ones but in here, it was stated that Bobby is too sickly. No other than that. Without realizing, thid story stirred so many emotions in me. I found myself laughing most of the times at their antiques, feeling my heart fluttering at the cheesy moments or just when the characters being so themseleves, I wished that I could be like them too. But oh well- im not in Hogwarts lol. In a nutshell, this fiction is solid 5 out of 5 stars. Good job.
NenaUnnie #4
Exo and Harry Potter are my two favourite things in the world, so you can imagine how excited I was when I discovered this fic. Of course, there are other kpop-hogwarts fics out there, but this one is by far the best one! I loved all of the characters, relationships between them and the way you developed them. What amazed me was how detailed and faithful your writing about the world of magic was, it was so similar to Rowling's that I was often forgetting this was fanfic and not a part of the canon. Of course, the romantic aspect of the story was beautiful, but I gotta say that the mystery part was amazing, you really brought back beautiful memories from my childhood, I was so immersed into the story and now I'm just sad that it's over. Thank you for this amazing story (as expected, cause I love all of your stories, you're one of my fave authors), it was cute, funny, beautiful and exciting. Love you, author-nim! (sorry if I made any mistakes, English is not my first language)
Bubbletea246 #5
Chapter 23: Never mind. Realised there's another chapter
Bubbletea246 #6
Chapter 22: Love this story but.... WHAT ABOUT BAEKHYUN?! My baby never got mentioned at the end
Gooine #7
Chapter 23: Stayed up till quarter to 6 to read this from 12 am in one go and it was worth every sec <3 my eyes are dying but dammed that was an amazing story. The most amazing thing was that it wasn't only the romantic relationship that was adorable and sweet but the different friendships that were formed and even with the other OCs. Krisho, baeksoo and chenyeol to name a few. Those friendships stuck out to me the most and we're truly friendship goals >_< (lol yifan and Suhos secret bubble bath toys, baekhyun undying love for kyungsoo and chanyeol and chens excessive pranking plus skinship- all of it was remarkably fresh and entertaining to read) But the couples were adorable baekyeol love and hate relationship, kai accepting kyungsoo despite his hobbies of dark magic, xuihan acting like an old sappy couple, fanxing awkward yet adorable uncertainty of the future, Chen and suho being completely opposites and the twin fashionista maknaes <3 (even if toahun weren't confirmed) All in only I love the backdrops/backstories, struggles they face even as ordinary teenagers such as exams and such. Props to you thou authornim I did not know it was y my bet was on Mr Jung but you proved me completely wrong~ I applaud you ^-^ I could say so much more but I'm dying so I think I gonna get some shuteye. You have an amazing gift of depicting pictures into words. Thank you so much authornim!!
Ps idk why but I just love the offhand comments about kris love/friendship for sehun and Tao especially the 'super lighter thing' or the 'defilminator' lol
charlottelehnsher #8
Chapter 8: Do you really have to use the R words?
themoonknows
#9
Chapter 22: Dear Merlin I can't believe I just discovered this masterpiece a week ago! I don't even know if you're still on here and read you comments, but I just have to tell you how much I loved this fic! It wa one of those stories that you can't stop reading even if it's too late and there's school tomorrow.

I've never read anything exo x HP related, and being the potterhead I am, I was slightly hesitant of wheter I should read this or not since I'm very picky about details and so on. But I can 100% confirm that this story did NOT disappoint, not even once! You made the universe so realistic and omg I can't begin to tell you how much I loved the four obstacles in the dungeons. And your work with the gigantic Hydra!!! 1000 poin to you, dear author.

I'm so happy that all the pairings worked out so well, and I'm really happy that both Yixing and Yifan got so important roles in this one since that's quite unusual. All the characters were portrayed so accurately and gosh, I just really loved every second I spent on reading this fic. Now, I will definitely look up your other stories. Warm hugs to you.
yutoppang
#10
Chapter 22: Came across this as it was listed in a recommended list, and I do not regret reading this at all!!! In fact, I read the whole thing in two days! XD It's really well written and the sorting you've given to each character seemed to fit so well that it was like a completed puzzle! OMG and your writing is amazing—you write so beautifully with a wide vocabulary and such vivid scenes that I could easily picture everything that was happening!!!
I love this so much; thank you for writing it!!! Keep on writing, friend! And, this story deserves all its love :)
taewho
#11
Chapter 22: THIS WAS SO GOOD
courtneylovesbacon
#12
Chapter 22: I randomly found this fic saved in my bookmarks and I was immediately hooked up after starting the first chapter. I love Harry Potter and seeing that world collide with Exo's was really amazing! I also want to give you props on the superb writing, all of your OCs were really unique, charming and funny which is rare, especially when it comes to fics - reading about them brought me back to the times when I was crazy about Harry Potter. I don't know how you managed to pull it off so well but the dynamics, atmosphere.. it really felt like a legit spin-off even though it's just fanfiction. Congratulations on this brilliant work!
30flowervictory30
#13
Chapter 23: Truth be told, I'm not an EXO fan but I have to say that stumbling across this fanfiction took me back to the years in which I filled myself with the Harry Potter series. Your story was amazing and breathtaking, and I enjoyed every single one of your chapters despite not knowing much about the characters themselves.
Thank you so much for writing!
MiszCJung #14
Chapter 23: Truly I cant neever ever had enough of Hogwarts adventure! This is truly amazing im trulyyyyy into the story that i just cant stop reading ;) so amazing their friendships are. And i love how strong each characters' personality and the plot is daebbakkk ;) its like the feeling of reading and watchibg Chamber of Secrets againnn~~~~
MiszCJung #15
Chapter 7: The HarryPotter and hogwarts never ever grows old x) and this is sooooo awesome! Im just soooo lovin it! ^^
teresaginny
#16
Chapter 23: Okay. First thing's first. Please tell me you're not J.K.Rowling who apparently fancies EXO and decided to made this story. Or else i'm going to force a veritaserum.
I mean, you are so incredibly good that this story totally drew me back to Hogwarts after years. I love you like Baekhyun love Kyungsoo.
I enjoy every bit of this fic, and i honestly feel bad that it has to end. But well, as Minseok said and i quote, "things just have to come to an end", what can we do about it.......
I love all the pairings despite of them not being the pairings i ship except Chanbaek and Kaisoo, also i usually don't like boyxboy so i kinda skip a lot of lovey dovey stuff, but i apreciate your hard work. I love how you use the Veil, the dark magic stuffs, Bloody Baron's soft spot on love, etc. Tho i was kinda hoping there would be a cameo of the golden trio on the death eater's incident or at least Harry's because he is the war hero and an auror at the time.
Now, someone asked about how Kyungsoo know about Prof. Jung being an auror, i assume it was because his dad (?).
Anyway, thank you so much for the story, it is really nostalgic and lovely, i really love it. You're awesome!!!
dreamshade
#17
Chapter 1: Just reading the first chapter and already found it interesting! So glad that I decided to click the subscribe button. I love everyone's character already and am looking forward to read the next chapters :D You did a good job writing this and seriously, you made me long for Harry Potter series. Thumbs up for you! <3 <3
61chanbaek4 #18
Chapter 22: This is just so ❤️ I don't even want it to end
jiashineees #19
i had a mindblown moment reading this. this is one of the best stories i've ever read.
unni_lau
#20
Chapter 4: I remember myself as not being the biggest HP fan, but still watched the movies when they came out. But i really like this fic so far :DDD