On July 12th, actress Han Chae Young wore a purple dress from Nina Ricci‘s fall/winter 2012 line toCartier‘s ‘Never Stop Tank‘ event.

On October 18th, Girls’ Generation‘s Jessica wore the same dress to W Korea‘s ‘Love Your W‘ event.  She altered the hem, making it much shorter than the original dress.

So, who wore it better?  Cast your vote and be sure to tell us why you voted that way in the comments!