Chapter 5: This is so freaking sad… the hardest act is what she is doing in real life.
It’s like Seungwan is the scriptwriter and she is the actress, acting according to her script. Can this be any sadder. 😭

Chapter 2: Cute!

Chapter 2: Congratulations

Chapter 10: Okay, wow. I have a lot to say but I don't know where to start. But then, let me start with, This Old Story top all the great Wendy and Irene pairing story I've read so far.

I kind of regret that I read it way too fast, then again, I know for sure that I'll revisit this for as long as this story lives. There would be a high change that I'll re-read this in my 30's, 50's and 70's. Who knows? Maybe when I'm near my death, I'd still held this story close. This story is that unforgettable and beautiful.

For a moment, I'm left thinking if it really became my number one for it's almost too easy to say that it is– and it is. It is remarkable and the emotional impact this story has me in chokehold. Also, it's been awhile since I uncontrollably cried, reading. I woke up with my eyes a bit swollen but no regrets!

And can I gush about how beautiful your writing is? It is simple and captivating that every words is to die for. All I see is best selling novelist. The quality and the thoughtfulness is just impeccable.

Reading this feels like falling in love.

It felt nostalgic as well, as if you're remembering the first love and heartbreak. And this is amazing! Something about this feels like you're watching a film and seeing the collective memories of how they (WenRenSeul) love someone so dearly, so selflessly and unconditionally that it's heartbreaking because love is supposedly selfish. I also felt terrified while reading this because of how delicate and vulnerable this is (knowing Seungwan's end) but it's encouraging and inspiring at the same time so I can't help but be overwhelmed with all the emotions raging within me. In best and worst way possible.

Hmm, I almost feel like I wanted to be loved by you. Like imagine, how lucky your muse will be. They will be immortal.

Ahh, this is just beyond beautiful that it makes me want to cry, again. I just love everybits of it, their love and determination, their misery and joy, their hope and realities. All of it fits perfectly. And the closure, thank goodness with the closure because I'll go mad and I'll probably mop for a couple of weeks if we didn't get any closer for all the three of them.

This is just the best. Thank you for writing and sharing your story with us. I hope you're always well and healthy! ❤💙💛

Chapter 6: Beautifully written. My heart ached so much which broke my knees amd weep. Thank you for bringing this story.

Chapter 10: Finally. Just...finally :')

/Let me go bawl some more

Chapter 7: Had to pause so many times to just breathe. It hurts so much.

You're an incredible writer

Chapter 5: I must be more of a masochist than I thought to be re-reading this during the holidays lmao I can't stop crying 😭

Chapter 3: Rereading and crying so bad still. Goddamn