I Should Have Told You

A Farewell

It's my fault. Every part of me is telling me this. It tried to rationalize it, because what could I have done? But a part of me keeps insisting if I had just met you, talked to you, I could have helped you hang on. I'm thinking of joining you. I honestly don't want to be in this world anymore, the world which places so little value in a human life. And am I to blame? Yes. I put you on a pedestal that you had no hope to get down from, and I foolishly believed that you were getting better. I should have known that it's not that easy, but I pretended and deluded myself that you were in a place you wanted to be. Now I don't know what to do. Do I just go on like nothing happened? I know I said last night I would just look back on you with fondness, but now I'm not sure if I can do that. So much hurts. There are so many things I should have told you, and the things I will never say will hurt me forever.

Part of me is angry at you. How could you leave us in this way? How could you forget about the people who loved you more than anything on this earth? Then I realized how selfish I was being. You lived to the best you could, and no one could have asked for any more. As much as I hate it, I think a tiny part of me will forever resent you for leaving and not taking me with you. I am broken too, but I held on because I had a reason to. Now I have one reason less.

I don't know what to do anymore. Do I cry? Do I move on? My family won't understand, they'll tell me to get over it because it's not like I knew you. And they're right. I didn't know the real you, and I will forever regret that. I'm sorry I failed you.

The first time I listened to SHINee, it was September 2016. I found Lucifer, and your shirt was the funniest thing I had seen in a while. I mean, where was the back? As time went on, I started to love your voice, and the raw emotions you brought to your music. Story Op 1 is one of my favourite things to listen to, but now how can I listen to it without hurting? I am honoured that I got to be with you for at least two comebacks, because I know there are people who didn't get to see any, just like there are people who have been with you since 2008. And we are all hurting. I don't even want to listen to SHINee anymore, because every note is too painful. But I am forcing myself to do it, because your memory deserves to be remembered, not as the idol who killed himself, but the passionate and enthusiastic man who stood up for what he believed in without a second thought, who poured his heart and soul into everything he did.

I can only leave you with what I would have said had I met you. How have you been? Are you eating lots? Please let me know if there's anything I can do for you. Are you happy? Do you need to talk about anything? Are the other members being nice to you? Are they teasing? I would like to thank you for creating music, and just for living, because your hope is my light in the darkness. Please keep fighting, because there is nothing I want more than for you to be happy.

And now you've moved on. What's it like there? I hope there's all of your favourite foods, and lots of places to rest and relax. May you look down on all of us, and protect us. But more importantly, protect your brothers. They are hurting so much more than me right now. Please comfort them, and tell them that it is not their fault. Let them continue their lives, whether it is as SHINee, or individually. I promise if I ever meet them, I'll make sure they are doing alright, and I'll tell them how valuable they all are, so that they don't feel alone.

And now, it's late December, and you can finally rest.

Jonghyun, you've done so well.

Like this story? Give it an Upvote!
Thank you!
AIMRWV
Trying to advertise this for the 18th but someone else is bidding really hard so I am running out of karma (already bought more for over 30dollars) so if you have some spare you are willing to donate, I would be really thankful.

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
Redofthedawn
#1
I'm aware that it isn't December but I just thought of this post. December will never be easy for a lot of us. I'm more aware of my depression around that time. I just became an adult and the realization that a lot can change has finally hit me. I'm not sure how to feel. People within my family have died or are dying and it seems like the only thing I'm allowed to do is move on. I'm no longer given the luxury of grieving the way I had with Jonghyun. There are so many fond memories that I can go back to with Jjong but for them I only have memories. So much has happened these past few years and while I'm not completely okay I can say there's plenty of room where I've healed.

As year 6 approaches I want my fellow Shawols to know that healing is hardly a linear task. It's okay to not be ready but where you are there's always going to be SHINee.

And Dear Author thank you for keeping this space for all of us.
luv_kero
2442 streak #2
Thank you for keeping this space for us for so many years <3 This milestone hit me a lot harder than expected, but seeing this brought so much comfort. Miss you to the moon and back, Jonghyun <3
Viola_Ella #3
Chapter 818: When I saw in newfeed I just realised today is the day. He is a sweet,kind and precious soul. I miss him.
Evelyn_64
#4
It’s been five years today and just a few days ago I turned 27, the age Jonghyun-ah was when we had to say goodbye to him. I have long since had to “become an adult” and learn what growing up means; yet every year I come back to this little space, and read some of the messages that people wrote for him, and think back to the letter I wrote at 22 and never shared with anyone. I think back to a memory of me looking at the full moon and talking to him for hours, telling him I missed him terribly. We still miss you, friend. I still remember you fondly. I still remember me at 17 dancing to Replay in my room. I’ll always cherish those memories of our Spring.



Author, I hope you have been doing well. Thank you so much for keeping this space running for so long, it brings comfort to some more than you’ll ever know.
OdetteSwan
928 streak #5
I'm so glad you won the bid. I will start collecting karma points again.
Good work.
OdetteSwan
928 streak #6
Chapter 818: I just really paid attention to SHINee this August. Yet, when Jonghyun passed away four years ago, I felt sad that another beautiful and caring person chose to leave this place. In fact, I didn't want to listen to any SHINee songs then.
Now, watching SHINee's MVs, I feel like I have accepted what happened and hope that he is really happy now.
Redofthedawn
#7
Time keeps moving on and I wonder why I can't just go back and fix things to when it was so peaceful. So much has happened in the last four years and it feels as though there's only SHINee left to comfort me. Jonghyun for so long I've written my letters to you and I couldn't this year because I couldn't find the strength or will to when I was feeling down. I haven't cried this much since I was a baby. I promised last year that I would tread the new year with caution and that didn't work out so great. There's more I wanna say but I just wish you knew how much I love you. Thank you for being born and sharing your light with the world. Sincerely I love you. 𝑰 𝒘𝒊𝒍𝒍 𝒂𝒍𝒘𝒂𝒚𝒔 𝒍𝒐𝒗𝒆 𝒚𝒐𝒖 ❤️
lovelyfeisty
#8
It’s been 4 years now and so it’s hard to believe that you left us, but I still do remember you as SHINee’s Blingbling Angel and as the brightest star that shines in the sky.

I used to feel so lonely after knowing that you left us, that I was listening to Lonely everyday for about a year, but now I just remind myself that you’re still with us, as the bright shining star watching over us from the night sky. ❤️
I will always love you.
wonpokemon
#9
i was InMemoryOfJonghyun!
just thought i'll let you know so you don't add this username again~ =]
anyways, good luck with the add and for all those who come here and are thinking of Jjong and of others and themselves.
aseulmonsta
#10
❤️