Comments: ブラックジャック Review Shop // CLOSED // BUSY + HIRING!

← Back to story

All Comments (45)

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
stellarstarlight
#1
I've always been curious about review shops. I could never do it myself. If you don't mind my asking, how did you come up with your rubric?
hwaranni #2
Chapter 10: hello! thank you so much for the review on my story, it's amazing how detailed you were. the amount of time spent waiting was worth it, istg. ♡
i just can't find the right words to express how grateful i am because you pointed on both the good and bad points and i really appreciate it! i feel motivated to start writing again as well as improving myself. i'm really glad you seemed to enjoy my story and yes, i agree - mafia!aus are precious. haha. again, thank you for the review! it was wonderful - you're all wonderful.
diamondELF193
#3
Hi there~ Just submitted for Puppy Love! Love lots <3
blacksmile
#4
Chapter 8: Okay I'm back! Ahh, about Chanyeol's character, I tried to portray him as someone who is a slow learner. Therefore his cognitive and behaviour development doesn't match his age. Plus, the environment he was in halt his development. I think it was my fault since I didn't emphasize on how he was treated differently in a severe protective manner by both Changmin's parents and the Kims. Since he was 'abnormal', both Changmin's parents and the Kims exclude him from the world in fear of Chanyeol getting hurt along the way through his adulthood. I've touched on this topic on the later chapter when Yifan discussed with Mrs Kim to take Chanyeol under his wings. Yifan convinced Mrs Kim that Chanyeol should not be treated any different from other 'normal' people and that he should be exposed to all the things kids his age are exposed too. He wants Chanyeol to explore the world and live the normal life he had missed before.

Honestly, i totally understand the uncomfortableness that creeps in while reading a few parts of this fanfic because when I reread those parts, I myself cringe in disbelieve like, 'wow did I actually write this part?'. So, it's cool.

Thank you for the awesome review!

Have properly credited you :D
blacksmile
#5
Chapter 8: Hai! I just noticed my review is up! I'm on my phone right now but I will get back to you and properly credit this shop once I got my hands on my laptop! :)
ali060903
#6
I've credited! :D
ali060903
#7
Hello! Thank you so much for spending time writing such a detailed, long and constructive review for my story. I promise I'll remember your suggestions and apply it into my future writing. Right now I'm on a trip so I just don't have a computer with me to credit you properly but I will as soon as I get home. And sorry for a short feedback because I still haven't gotten time to read it fully but I will leave a comment once again after I read it twice for more details. Thanks your shop for offering me a chance to improve myself! XOXO
jaxial
#8
Chapter 7: I've picked up my review! I have to say, I honestly just expected something short, not a whole planned out thing with sections on plot and whatnot.

Thank you so much for the honest review! I never really knew what to think of the story, as I was writing based on real-life emotions and I was kinda upset at the time, so I didn't really pay much attention to the little details. Actually the little scenes with Miss Gayoung were a little off, but to me she is a crucial mentor, someone really improtant to me in my life but as another person.

And the Chinese at the end, it was actually a confession to that one person I wrote this for, and he'd know if he read it. As I mentioned, I was distraught at that time, so I was just really concerned about it and I wanted to let him know what I really feel. So this wasn't really a story for readers but more of a letter to a special someone. I actually just wanted to review it cuz I thought it was written really badly and I needed another opinion.

Thanks so much!
proudjbstan
#9
i requested :)
LetsMeetInOurDreams5
#10
Hi! I've requested :)
Amalya
#11
I know you're closed at the moment, but I've requested for a review. Thank you!
flowergirl #12
Just requested for The Long Way Home!
Debaekyeol
#13
CONGRATS ON YOUR ONE MONTH ANNIVERSARY OF YOUR SHOP ♡(ノ´ヮ`)ノ*: ・゚
(I'm sorry I'm late, I've been a mess. Ily~)
aibeast
#14
Chapter 5: Thank you for the review. I am pleasantly surprised that the second chapter got a good response because honestly, I was worried that it was not that good. I rarely ever write first person pov so I am glad there were not a lot of mistakes in the technicality of it and is easy to read. Thank you so much for the insights!
raelio
#15
Chapter 6: THANK YOUUU! Just what I needed! Your review if very much appreciated, I needed a reader's POV so yeah~ I now know which parts to revise <3 thank you so much!
Debaekyeol
#16
I finally requested, Casheeew~ x3
AceBaseFaceSpace
#17
I really though the whole Review Shop thing was cool, and well organized. I'll tell others about it, and come back later.
Snowcakie
#18
I have requested again! :)