Is Writing Fanfiction Morally Right?

I watched a video on youtube earlier today about how disgusting shipping Idols together was.

The creator of the video ranted about how it was morally wrong to ship two idols together and how it is wrong for the fans of these idols, who are very close friends, to over analyse and ualise everything those two do together, whether it be a picture they take together or them even glancing at each other.

To be honest, the question of whether fanfiction is right or wrong is quite redundant and inconsequential to many people on this site and many people in fandoms of any type, whether it be Kpop or for western bands and TV shows. 

Most people who write fanfiction do it for fun, as a pass time or a hobby, as I do. I write fanfiction because it's all fun, it's just a pass time to me and I have always enjoyed writing, and writing fanfiction for this site was just a way of getting my writing out there. I enjoy getting feedback and reading the stories on this site, stories that have creative concepts, interesting characters and talented writing. Writing fanfiction has helped me develop my writing and I feel I have improved a lot since I started.

The problem, it seems, the reason why many people don't agree with fanfiction, is because the people we write about are actual people with actual lives and friendships. We must never forget that everybody, including idols, are entitled to their own privacy, to keep certain things in their lives a secret, or to give out information about certain things in their lives, but only if they want to. Sometimes people can get carried away with these things, we all look down on Saesangs because we know they are all bat crazy people who cross the line by miles, but sometimes we can cross the line ourselves without realising it.

We need to remember something in this fandom.

Not every Kpop idol is gay.

Statistically, of course, there are bound to be some idols that are lesbian, homoual or biual, but not every Kpop idol is gay, that is statistically impossible. What? Do SM, YG, JYP, BIGHIT and all the other kpop companies only scout gay people and push them back into the closet before debuting them?

These groups are not having some massive backstage before performing for us, and although there may be some gay or lesbian or biual idols that we don't know about, and maybe two idols of the same are romantically involved, but not everybody is gay, and it is kinda stupid to assume such a thing.

The majority of idols are going to be straight, and we've seen some scandals involving idols dating each other. I've been in this fandom for a miniscule four years now and in that time I have seen so many dating scandals happen. Zico and Sooyoung, Kai and Krystal, Jiyong and Nana, Jiyong and Jooyeon, Baekhyun and Taeyeon, Luhan and Xiaotong just to name a few.

But even though Kai has been involved in the scandal with Krystal, people are still convinced he's out -ing Kyungsoo (or the other way round), and even though Baekhyun was caught dating Taeyeon, people still believe he is jumping Chanyeol every time they see each other.

Yes, I ship so many people, such as Kaisoo and Baekyeol, who doesn't? But some people need to realise that they are just friends, and will most likely stay best friends all their lives. 

Yoongi and Jimin are probably not going to date, and Jungkook and Taehyung are probably not taking it in turns to each other off. Namjoon is probably the straightest idol we've ever seen, but apparently he can't resist Jin's international handsomeness.

We need to draw the line between our fantasies and reality and make sure we stay on the line of reality.

Though fanfiction is harmless most of the time, if you go crazy and start blogging about how they glanced at each other that one time on stage, or the fact they posted a selca of the two of them smiling, that's when shipping can be harmful. It makes idols become scared to spend time with each other or post pictures of each other because they become sick of all the comments screaming "OMG BAEKYEOL IS ING REAL!" or "KAISOO!". 

Idols have even been propositioned face to face and asked by fans about shipping and whether they are dating or whether they should or not. This is so wrong.

As I said, statistically there are going to be idols that are interested in the same and there are probably members of a band that are actually dating each other, but that is not any of our business. It's not for us to know whether they are gay or not, and it is up to them to tell us when they are ready.

We must remember that the culture in Korea is different to ours. Although it is sad and it is difficult for us to understand in our society, it is not as simple as it seems, especially if you are an idol. But now idols are becoming more fearless and confident. Luhan was not scared to announce his relationship with the beautiful Xiaotong, and didn't beat around the bush about it, and I applaud his confidence to take control of the situation, although not every idol has that freedom it is always good to see idols becoming so fearless.

And let's not forget our first openly gay idol, Holland. Having an openly gay idol is a huge step for us and hopefully his honesty will encourage other idols to be honest with us as well, but until they do, it is not up to us to try and force them into nonsensicle relationships with their best friends.

We need to keep fanfiction and shipping to ourselves, and to not it in our idols faces. We need to respect them and realise that the relationships we fantasise about will never be more then just friendships.

This also goes beyond the kpop fandom, we must respect other people as well, because it is so sad how many other people are into these fictitious relationships that make them uncomfortable and can even ruin friendships.

Please spread the message, we need to respect idols, we need to respect everybody. 

Thank you for reading this rant, it was actually longer then I expected but I had a lot on my mind after the video I watched. Fanfiction for the most part is harmless, but some people just take it too far.

Anyway, thank you for reading, I may actually start updating soon :-D

Sorry for going on and on, let me know what you guys think down in the comments. Maybe I've triggered some Saesang? That would make my day :-D

See ya!

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
buriedphoenix
#1
I agree. Reminds me of the time I wrote up a whole essay about shipping edits of idols and how much pissed me off (or shipping in general) and a friend of mine wrote a wonderful comment about real life and shipping (and consequences therefore).
But the fact we call those dating scandals just saddens me, they are humans with feelings and emotions and fans plainly disregard it in favour of their "superior" ship and member xy should get off member yz's back because they watched A TWO HOUR ANALYSIS VIDEO OF SHIP VW AND YZ! and they must , because VW and YZ are Real. Even going as far as putting it out into the idols faces...
Not only can they be interested in the same , but it would make me uncomfortable if u get seriously shipped with a friend of mine who's a sibling to me or because the other person could even be ace, aro and whatnot.
But that's also a problem thanks to the labels and the image they paint of their artists and/or fans that take it too seriously.
I also ship, but not romantically, even if my writing might paint a different painting. A friend once told me that they ship baeksoo romantically and I should watch the two hour something analysis of chanbaek being an item because its really in depth and they can see that there might be truth innit.
I just wanted to cry....
Anyway, thanks for the rant ✌🏻
xGummyPandax
#2
I completely agree with you, people sometimes just take it too far. I'd be equally mortified and pissed if someone tried asking, anyone really, if they shipped or ed someone. Specially in a fan meeting.
YoruNoTenshi
#3
Personally, I don't write ships (the 2 romance fics I have were per request). My stories are usually friendship only, and because of that, a lot of people don't like me as an author. But I will comment how scary it is that there are a lot of delusional fans out there. I remember when so many people were mad when Taeyeon/Baekhyun and Tiffany/Nichkhun happened because fans would rather kill themselves than realize that Taeny are just friends and Khuntoria wasn't real. Or when Krystal was called a for dating Kai and "taking him away from D.O.", or BoA getting hate for becoming such close friends with Yunho after the TVXQ/JYJ split, because some "fans" believed it was her fault for breaking apart YunJae -_- the list is endless.

I'm not sure if those fans know, or maybe that they probably refuse to acknowledge that Korea still has a very negative view towards LGBT for the most part. Fans constantly insisting that all our faves are having with each other non-stop can actually become dangerous for them. When Yunho and Jaejoong were at the military, it was getting to the point where a lot of Cassies had to be reminded to chill with the YunJae theories and stuff, because homoual acts on camp grounds could cause them to get a dishonorable discharge.

Basically, whenever an idol (especially a male idol) gets into a relationship, I'm so scared for the person they're dating. Because fans think they own idols, and that their ship is so real, that they start threatening the person they're involved with. It's not fair to them, because they found someone they love and instead of happiness they get death threats from delulus -_- Sungmin and his wife are a good example, because 3 years later and they're still going through hard times because of fans.

My friend was a huge 1D fan, and I remember her telling me that 2 of the members went from being best friends to distant strangers because the fans were shipping them so much, even after they asked the fans to stop. It freaked them out that any tiny movement they made was considered a ual act towards each other, that their relationship pretty much became nonexistent. I don't want to see that happen to any of my groups, but at this rate it's totally possible.

Anyway, I'm pretty sure my comment didn't make much sense, but I'm really glad you wrote this. I think that forcefully insisting that 2 people are dating is just as rude and weird as refusing to accept that two people are dating (did that make sense?)
MissMinew
#4
I have a question. It’s a legit question.
Why is it, that every time fan fiction (as a genre) is brought up, it’s always the question of “all your idols aren’t gay?”
Really?
Do I really believe my idols are mentally ill just because the characters in my stories are? Do I truly believe they’re criminals just because they’re criminals in my stories?
Do people who write wolf!AU honestly believe their idols are half werewolf?

The answer should be no because obviously itd be stupid to believe they are werewolves and it’d be sad to believe they’re all mentally ill and/or criminals.

Are people who write straight couples ultimately more “right” because statistically there are more straight idols?

Why is it always the “not all idols are gay” question that is asked.
Why not “not all idols are straight”?

Look, I agree. Not all idols are gay. So what? Not all idols are straight either. So what?
Does that really mean writing gay fan fiction suddenly makes it immoral? Does it mean seeing two people of opposite interact suddenly mean they’re straight? Do all dating scandals really count as the truth?

I’m fully with you on the “not throwing it in their face”. They’re human, they deserve their privacy and that includes their uality, their romance and all such aspects of their life. Shipping should be a private thing done between fans, not something shoved in our idols faces.

I just don’t understand why we need to question authors who write gay relationships when it comes to the morality of writing fanfiction when there are so many other aspects of writing.
And I don’t understand why it’s always targeted towards gay shippers when straight shippers can be just as delusional, just as provocative and just as demanding of their ships. A bad shipper is a bad shipper. Why do we always question the gays?
Kurottoki
#5
/claps/
Uunbiiyan
#6
Oh my god thank you for writing this, I agree so much. It's kinda scary how delusional some people can be. I've seen people say some pretty crazy stuff. Like in january Chanyeol posted a picture to instagram for either Kyungsoo or Kai's birthday. It was a screenshot of a group chat and baekhyun was in it, his name was written as 백현이 (baekhyun-i). And someone commented something along the lines of "baekhyun-i? Omg chanbaek is real!!". It was one of the most baffling things I've ever read.

I'm not really into shipping so I don't exactly see the appeal. Although I sometimes ship whoever I think looks cute together, but in more of a friendship type way. I don't mind shipping but some just take it way too far. Especially the ones that think their ship is ~SO REAL~. Pls stop k thnx.