A Rookie's Review and Theory of Red Velvet's Rookie

[Edit: There are 66 Rookies in the entire song]

Heyo heyo Red Velvet fans (hopefully soon we will have a fandom name!) Apologies for the punny title... XD

So as you know, Red Velvet's Rookie was released at 12 AM KST today, and I'm sure you watched it. If not, don't worry because I linked the video... here's my review and opinion on the song, music video, and individual girls!

Song: 6/10 stars

Let's be real, Red Velvet has some really nice vocalists (Wendy, Seulgi, and Joy) and this song did NOT at all let them shine in the vocals. Here's my biggest pet peeve... "HIGH PITCHED TONE SPEAKING" This goes for the chorus "rookie rookie" and all the "rap" lines for Irene and Joy. The lines weren't raps or singing... it was this high pitched tone speaking. And the beginning with Irene's "rap" is really cringey tbh... she can rap, but this song does not let her shine. 

But I do have to say one thing.. it's catchy af.. "rookie rookie" although it sounds more like "lookie lookie." For the catchiness of the song I would give it a 8/10... only the chorus is catchy. The random rifts from Seulgi and Wendy during the chorus feel out of place as well. I think with this song, they were going for another "Dumb Dumb," but let's just say it's different.

Music Video: 8/10 Stars

WTF is the entire music video? XD I did really enjoy it, although it was really weird. It's a really colorful and unique music video and I give kudos for the unique shots and storyline. Here's my theory on the video:

Joy brings drugs or perfume or something and all the other girls are exposed to it. 

x06CuAD.png

Yeri and Irene are immediately hit with (we'll call it the perfume).

However, Seulgi and Wendy are not really affected (at first).

Seulgi tries to fight it, but eventually succumbs to it when she opens the door and walks into a new "world."

Wendy is the last "normal" person. She tries to lead the girls out, but eventually succumbs to the new "world." Also, creepy Irene?

I think Joy was trying to contain all the craziness, hence her trying to close the doors to the other "world." But in the end, it all explodes.

(also.. does this not look like from One of These Nights when Irene was blown away by the water??)

And from here on out, I have no idea what's happening. All I know is that Irene is shady and in the end she might have been the one controlling them all, hence her being the puppeteer.

Concept and Individual Styling: 9.5/10 Stars

Everyone looks so adorable... my personal favorites are Irene's braided pigtails and Seulgi's "horn" hair. I'm really loving all the hair colors, they're subtle but pretty. And thank the heavens for no more cheeto hair XD

Overall: 7.83/10 Stars

My comeback rankings.

1. Dumb Dumb

2. Ice Cream Cake

3. One of these nights

4. Russian Roulette

Tied 5th place - Happiness and now Rookie


Okay let's begin the second by second review of the video.

0:00 - Ooh the beginning is the teaser! I love the vibrant colors! And to the people who say that Red Velvet has the same music, please watch this! 

0:17 - IRENE IS GORGEOUS! I just love the reddish hair in the braided pig tails. 

0:19 - Finally Irene gets to rap... oh nevermind, it's more like "speaking words in a high toned pitch" 

0:26 - Same with Joy. WTF, that's not rapping, that's not singing either... not a big fan of the high pitched tone talking. Also just wanted to say that I'm a huge fan of Joy's short hair, not that I mind the long hair.

0:27 - Huh? Is that some sort of drug that Joy is holding?

0:30 - Yep... it's drugs.

0:32 - ITS MY BABY SEULGI! Her red hair looks sooooo good. I'm still bitter over the cheeto hair from Russian Roulette.

0:40 - It's Wendy! Ooh, the dark navy hair color looks good on her as well. What is this song's obsession with "high pitched tone talking?"

0:48 - Seulgi being dragged into the closet is me being dragged into Red Velvet's charms XD

0:51 - So Irene wasn't behind Seulgi's closet... dang my poor Seulrene heart.

1:00 - It's our maknae Yeri!

1:06 - Loving this Alice in the Wonderland concept.

1:07 - DANCE BREAK B*TCHES!

1:11 - I like this reoccuring theme in Red Velvet's music video where they have a bunch of themselves.

1:23 - And here we have the creepy Irene XD

1:26 - Also pyromaniac Irene

1:30 - Seulgi is so freakin adorable with the mustache

1:35 - Loving the hairstyle

1:37 - OH NO WENDY!!! drugs??

1:40 - JOY IM DONE XD WHAT EVEN IS THAT FACE

1:42 - I like these shots of them in the chair, although the angle of their neck makes me uncomfortable

1:52 - Ugh the high pitched tone speaking again

2:04 - Oh shoot the set looks so cool with all the moving parts.. I can't wait for the behind the scenes

2:18 - Rookie rookie... damn I will admit that this song is catchy af But it kind of sounds like "Lookie lookie"

2:30 - ahhh this scene looks like from One of these nights when Irene is blown away by the water!!

2:31 - Finally some nice vocals from Seulgi and Wendy

2:33 - WHERE IS MY CRAZY MAKNAE PARK SOOYOUNG?

2:47 - THAT HAIR FLIP BY IRENE GOT ME SHOOK

2:51 - WTF

3:00 - EVEN MORE WTF... what in the world is happening... UFOs??

3:11 - Oooh i like the dance

3:19 - SO IS IRENE CONTROLLING EVERYONE WTF

3:51 - Well it's over now and it was a lot to process..


PLEASE COMMENT BELOW YOUR IDEAS AND FEELINGS ON THIS COMEBACK!

 

 

 

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
xx8472T
#1
Haha!!! I never thought of the music video that way. But you're totally right - all 5 RV members really do look like they're high... I was sort of freaked out when I first saw the MV XD.

I'm glad we think alike on the "high pitched speaking." That really hit a sore spot after all of the recent "high pitched squeaking" comebacks from other girl groups. For me, the chorus was the big NO but everything else was okay. I liked Seulgi's and Wendy's parts. Their voices SLAYED, as usual.

I really, really like the dance for this comeback. RV's dances are always fantastic - and Rookie's choreography sure lived up to my expectations. Like you, Dumb Dumb and Ice Cream Cake are probably my favorite comebacks. Those were fantastic.

I noticed that you didn't like Russian Roulette? I didn't like it either XD. I'm sort of disliking the concept RV is heading towards (the bright, flashy, plain ODD concept). Lol it seems that we think alike... ;)
dyoyahhh
#2
We forgot one very important, and huge hint, which might be the key to the whole mystery and storyline-
the ROOKIE guy! (the person covered with flowers lol)

idk if it's really called rookie but i'll call it rookie xD It could be something, someone, or just an imaginary character that was formed because of the 'perfume'..

Anyway I really love this comeback. If it doesn't favor some of you guys, try to give it another listen, or watch it along with the choreo!
The choreo is lit. The song is catchy. The MV is interesting. The album is beautiful. It is a waste if you say it's a flop when you just listened to the song once.
If you still don't like it, it's okay there's another comeback in the future :3 but believe me one day you'll go 'lookie lookie ma super lookie lookie boy' 'lookie lookie lookie' because it's just so catchy xD It suits them so much. And another thing, they smile a lot and looks so adorable, cute and happy in Rookie, and it's kinda refreshing :D
IndonesianPotat
#3
Try to listen to it for a few more times, I think for most people it would take some times for them to actually like the song.. though, I'm sad that there are a lot of hates coming to them this comeback :( I'm just hoping that they won't be too affected by it and know that their fans will always got their back
Ai_Akizuki
#4
I'm still trying to understand the music video btw. Is Irene being the puppeteer means that she's the one who's actually evil or what??
SheirynFiya
#5
Omg I agree. They all look stunning of course, its red velvet. But im peeved about the fact that great vocalists like seulgi and wendy; their vocals are wasted on these kind of songs. SM, seriously? It sounds like a children song ro me, not as catchy as russian roulette but still average. But their powerful vocals cant shine here
Ai_Akizuki
#6
Creepy Irene seems y tho but yeah the song isn't my type actually but since I promise to myself that I'll like their comeback song I'll make myself do ==
poorpho
#7
They look so good in this comeback ugh!
I did like the song tho. It took a few listens, but I've been banging my head to it in the car all day. That bass tho, man. I love me some nice bass