{review} Calling PixieDream

by 500sunny500 and mangogogo |
Tags   apply   graphics   iusinger   ljoe   request   review   shop   | Report Content

(Choose a subject)
If reporting plagiarism, please provide links or sources to the original work.
Please ensure to elaborate on the issue for us to form an actionable response.


View Your Reports

{review} Calling PixieDream - apply graphics iusinger ljoe request review shop - main story image

A A A A

Deadly Deal: Hidden Love by PixieDream


Title (4/5)

I've seen these kind of titles before, so it doesn't really interest me. So far, I only understand how "Deadly Deal" relates to the story, but not the "Hidden Love" part.

 

Appearance (0/5)

The font is hard to read, Sandara is pretty blurry, and…Okay, let me just say that you need a better poster. All I can get from this poster is that there's G-Dragon and Sandara in this fanfic.

 

Description/Foreword (6/15)

First of all, take out the author's note about saying that it's not your first time in AFF and etc. That's not needed in the description.

Second of all, if it's rated, you rate the whole story. You don't just say that the story is rated at the bottom of the page. The rule states that you should rate the story for mature contents, which includes extreme violence and sexual activity.

Other than that, I found parts of the description confusing. For an example, in the foreword I couldn't tell if the text switched from paragraph to paragraph until I read it through multiple of times.

 

Plot (23/25)

I could've given you full points if you haven't made the deal between the devil and Ji Yong. There are a ton of fanfics out there where when a character dies, he or she makes a deal with the devil or whoever and is given a chance to live. However, I gave you most points because I kind of like how the girl is suffering because of his "death," but he has to make her own life suffer.

 

Characters (10/15)

The characters aren't really unique. However, I do love Ji Yong's character here in this story. It fits the plot very well. 

 

Writing (Spelling/Grammar/Punctuation) (14/20)

You just had a couple of errors here and there. Some of them were really big errors, and others were pretty small errors. However, when I read some parts of the story, I was a bit confused with the plot and what was going on. In some chapters, you also bolded the whole chapter out. You should unbold the chapters unless you want to emphasize a certain word in the chapter.

 

Chapter 1:

Incorrect:

This overly sweet guy is called Dong Youngbae. Dara's best friend since birth.

"What's with the frowning face, Dara-ah?" She pouted and pointed at her stupid classmates. "I see, don't mind them, they will just give you headache." She nodded and smiled.

"By the way, where's Jiyoung?" She looked around; hoping to spot his golden hair but found no trace. "Why is he not here yet?"

 

Correct:

This overly sweet guy was called Dong Youngbae, and he was Dara's best friend since birth.

"What's with the frowning face, Dara-ah?" She pouted and pointed at her stupid classmates. "I see. Don't mind them, they will just give you a headache." She nodded and smiled.

"By the way, where's Jiyoung?" She looked around, hoping to spot his golden hair. However, she  found no trace. "Why is he not here yet?"

 

Chapter 5:

Incorrect: 

"You wouldn't tell will you oppa? I really need it right now and even you can't stop me!" She pushed Yongbae off from blocking her door. He landed with an "ooff". She quickly grabbed the door and closed it.

"Dara."

Before h can stop her, she quickly turned on the engine and drove off. Leaving Yongbae behind dumbfounded.

 

Correct: 

"You wouldn't tell, would you, Oppa?" I really need it right now, and even you can't stop me!" She pushed Yongbae away from her door. He landed with an "oof" as she quickly grabbed the door and closed it.

"Dara."

Before he could stop her, she quickly turned on the engine and drove off, leaving Yongbae behind, dumbfounded.

 

Flow (4/5)

I think that the flow is going a bit too fast, but I don't really have a huge issue with the flow.

 

Overall Enjoyment (6/10)

This is my first DaraGon fanfic I've read, and I kind of enjoyed it. If you go back to your story and fix up your errors, then I might've enjoyed it more.

 

Total: 67/100 (67%)

Comments

Comments are moderated. Keep it cool. Critical is fine, but if you're rude to one another (or to us), we'll delete your stuff. Have fun and thanks for joining the conversation!

You must be logged in to comment.

500sunny500 [A]  on says:
@reeseee3: Sorry! We're closed! >.< However, we made a new request shop right here:
http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/231323
The forms are the same, so you can just copy and paste! :D

reeseee3  on says:
Hi, I would like to request a poster :)

Title of story: 그대와 같아 (Same As You)

Link to story: http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/171470/same-as-you-fluff-romance-ledappleband-ledapple-hanbyul-janghanbyul

Authors(s): reeseee3

Profile link: http://www.asianfanfics.com/profile/view/138048

Type of graphic: poster please!

Mood: cute

Quotes: none

Character Images: Jason Jang (Hanbyul): http://i71.photobucket.com/albums/i145/reese94/GJason.jpg
Lila Cho: http://i71.photobucket.com/albums/i145/reese94/GLila.jpg

Anything else? I chose the pictures I did because I envisioned Hanbyul taking a selca with Lila behind him. If you could possibly make the poster that way, I would greatly appreciate it! :)

Thank you so much! :)

500sunny500 [A]  on says:
@scarlettwolf: I think I understand what you mean. However, in our current generation, we use single spaces instead of double spaces. Double spaces were used a long time ago because it was harder to tell if the punctuations were single spaced. Nowadays, we can easily tell the spaces because each key on your keyboard uses up to same. I'm not sure if I got your point, but here's the link where I got all this information: http://desktoppub.about.com/cs/typespacing/a/onetwospaces.htm

scarlettwolf  on says:
It appears to be AFF... =/ (at least in the comments)
Well anyways, as long as you know about it(like how to double space), I'm fine with it.

scarlettwolf  on says:
hmm...
Well, I think it's AFF. It looks like there is only one space when there are really two...
It's in every chapter I think too. But it seems it's AFF...
Hi. I'm scarlettwolf
Hi. I'm scarlettwolf

500sunny500 [A]  on says:
@scarlettwolf: We're not exactly sure what you're talking about. ^^;; Would you please mind pointing out the chapter we made our mistake on?

scarlettwolf  on says:
AYO! ^^
Not really gonna say too much, and I have no idea if this is just AFF being weird, but after a period, exclamation mark, etc. you need to have double spacing. Like right there.
Maybe it's just AFF formatting, I couldn't really tell... ._.

RaspberriCloud  on says:
I know it seems weird with the indents... I though I fixed them. Well you see, I kinda went on a 4-6 month long hiatus and I lost track of the stuff I wrote before hand. I will try to fix up where you said. Also it was a apply fix and after a month or so of waiting I got impatient and just chose the first appliers. Heh heh. I'm glad for your review! Thank you!

doramaaprncss  on says:
I'll credit you tomorrow, okay?

doramaaprncss  on says:
thanks :)

Log in to view all comments and replies


^ Back to Top